screw_ball Wrote:Seriously, this guy has to be selfish as f.uck if he won't share something like this.
If I had won it and came on here & read something like this, I don't think it would inspire me to hurry and share it for free with everyone who
didn't pay $280US for the tape.
If something of this calibre ever appears on eBay again, the hipbase should be more organized in getting together a group bid.
I'd suggest something like 1 person collect a certain $ amount from everybody who would like a copy (via PayPal). If the item isn't won, everybody's donation towards the auction is refunded. If the item is won, all those that contributed get a copy before it is publically shared.
This way, it's not 1 person spending a huge amount of money then having to consider whether or not to share it, but a group, each putting in an equal share and taking an equal "hit".
Yeah, it was hostile. It's his cassette, at any rate, so I can;t complain if he doesn't share.
maybe you could collect money and offer to split the cost with him...or something?
rocketsan22 Wrote:maybe you could collect money and offer to split the cost with him...or something?
Count me in for that, to hear that would be freakin awesome
Chris4613 Wrote:rocketsan22 Wrote:maybe you could collect money and offer to split the cost with him...or something?
Count me in for that, to hear that would be freakin awesome
Me too.
I think It's important for a piece like this to be distributed, even just for the sake of preservation. As far as we know its the only copy around(outside of the Hip's Vault's probably) and if something should befall it, it would be lost. How can the winner be possessive? He'd always own the master, the official source.
I guess it's just my opinion that it would be his duty to allow others(at their expense) to copy/share. I knew if I obtained it, even for whatever number, I would realize that it's a little bit of music history, and you can't own that.
I love your method, SRB. In the future, I'd like to organize something like that if another oportunity like this arises.
Corby Wrote:I guess it's just my opinion that it would be his duty to allow others(at their expense) to copy/share. I knew if I obtained it, even for whatever number, I would realize that it's a little bit of music history, and you can't own that.
I love your method, SRB. In the future, I'd like to organize something like that if another oportunity like this arises.
One other point of my group-bid suggestion, is that it would have to be kept a secret how many people donated to the cause, because otherwise, somebody could read how many people are in the group-bid, and know exactly how much money the total bid would be.
As for duty to share, it's nobody's duty...just like it's nobody's duty to share the live recordings that people record. It's done by tapers who
want to share their recordings, but by no means do they
have to, and the winner of the tape would have to
want to share it.
Anybody who is angry with the winner for not sharing it now, should have placed a higher bid, hence my group-bid suggestion.
Corby, yu're thinking from your own (clearly admirable) mindset.
Who's to say this guy didn't bid on it because he recognised the chance to make a profit??
If we can raise enough money - I have been in contact with the seller for a couple of weeks - he offered it to me for $150.
I do not agree with paying for Hip "bootlegs", and I am not convinced that this is something that we do not all already have - maybe just some of the song titles have been changed.
Just food for thought.
Interesting... I don't have much, but I'd be willing to chip in ten pounds or so ($22.59 canadian, apparantly)
Tthip Wrote:If we can raise enough money - I have been in contact with the seller for a couple of weeks - he offered it to me for $150.
I do not agree with paying for Hip "bootlegs", and I am not convinced that this is something that we do not all already have - maybe just some of the song titles have been changed.
Just food for thought.
If he's willing to take a hit of $130 something seems a bit fishy... but then again, if it is, he should return it to the seller.
Hmmm... I'm in for $20.
chris Wrote:If he's willing to take a hit of $130 something seems a bit fishy... but then again, if it is, he should return it to the seller.
Hmmm... I'm in for $20.
I spoke to him the day the auction started - and he kept in contact with me. He said he would be willing to make me a copy, but he would like some cash depending on how the price of the auction went. When it closed at $300 he offered it to me at half.
I have not talked to him in a week, since I said - thanx but !!!!!!!!$150!!!!!!!
wait, $150 for a copy!
hock:
Also - the kid that won the auction has a username of Jason Devries.
I swear in the Hip circles over the past years I have run across that name.
It says he is from Ontario - anyone know the guy?
I've seen that name around as well... but can't place it.