[Roy-at-tth]

where's the U2 love?

[direwolf74]

1. I don't think you can count the Nirvana box as an album...none of it was recorded in 2004, and more importantly it's not an album!

Who cares? Yes it was recorded years ago, but 90% of the material hasn't seen the light of day until now, so in my opinion it officially counts as a 2004 release. Last year I had Led Zep's "How the West Was Won" on my list. Should I not have counted that one as well?? It's my list and I can add whatever I want to it, thank you very much.

[direwolf74]

where's the U2 love?

No kidding, eh. I figured more people would have them on their list. We haven't heard from everybody yet though, so let's wait and see. I'm sure there's plenty of U2 love out there in hipbase land.

[The Darkest Canuck]

Statues-Auxillary
Hands Of Death-s/t promo
The Comeback Kid-Turn It Around
True Theories-s/t
Despised Icon-Consumed By Your Poison
All Purpose Voltage Heroes-The End Of Daniel Johnathan Poole
Dead Jesus-...Let Them Suffer
The Doers-Ready, Set, ...Do
A Day And A Deathwish-s/t
The Sourkeys-s/t

there's 10 that all could've easily made my list

whatta ya think????????????

[The Darkest Canuck]

Who cares? Yes it was recorded years ago, but 90% of the material hasn't seen the light of day until now, so in my opinion it officially counts as a 2004 release.

i've heard pretty much everything in that box set already except for do rei me, and some of the demos (most of which are of songs that were released). there's really not that much in the box that is really all that rare at all, but it's still worth getting because the recordings of the "rarities" will finally be of good sound quality, and of course, because of the DVD. Personally, i would've preferred an Unplugged in New York DVD or Live Sold Out Tonight DVD to the box set, but hopefully we'll get those soon enough too.

[Littleproud]

Nice call on the Doers...mike watt is still king!

[keithtalent]

I'm going to limit this to my top 8:

1. The Futureheads - S/T
2. The Tragically Hip - In Between Evolution
3. Arcade Fire - Funeral
4. The Streets - A Grand Don't Come For Free
5. The Libertines - S/T
6. Franz Ferdinand - S/T
7. Morrissey - You Are The Quarry
8. Interpol - Antics