11-02-2004, 12:24 PM
Glad you liked it, Fingernails. Unfortunately my little exercise hasn't generated the discussion I hoped it would. But it's a really fun thing to do :thumb:
I stand by Gus/Cordelia being a tie, but the consensus is probably right that Pistols beats Makeshift (although they're quite different songs, hard to compare). On the other hand, I've since concluded that 'Family' beats 'Gems' because it's a more ambitious 'major' song where Gems---while perfect---is a modest tune by definition. So my number stays the same, for what it's worth.
I stand by Gus/Cordelia being a tie, but the consensus is probably right that Pistols beats Makeshift (although they're quite different songs, hard to compare). On the other hand, I've since concluded that 'Family' beats 'Gems' because it's a more ambitious 'major' song where Gems---while perfect---is a modest tune by definition. So my number stays the same, for what it's worth.