Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

What's with the recent setlists?
#16

spottrax Wrote:Thats quite a list! If you count all the covers, they've played probably around 125 songs total this tour. Other than Pearl Jam, I cant think of another band that does that many different songs in a single tour!

you don't listen to jam bands :mrgreen:

gov't mule, tea leaf green, phil lesh...
these bands will do 3-4 night runs without repeating 1 song

not that the hip don't mix it up...because they do! (just not enough)

when i saw gov't mule @ the kool haus [Dec 1, 2005 + Dec 1, 2006] they only repeated 1 song from the previous show (and they only repeated it, since they had the guy who composed the song guest with them on stage)
42 different songs out of 43 songs played....
that's what i call mixing it up
Reply
#17

Remember, Gord can't remember lyrics very well!!!
Reply
#18

Speaking of jam bands, I can't wait for the multi-day campout the Hip are going to put on (a la Phish and Coventry) when they finally do call it quits. I'm not pulling for an end to the Hip, mind you, but it will come someday. And I just hope they go out with a bang: playing outdoors next to some beautiful lake for hours and covering just about every song they've ever written, making us forget we ever griped about setlists.
Reply
#19

sullivand Wrote:(a la Phish and Coventry)

with less mud
Reply
#20

haha that would be awesome a 6 hour set
Reply
#21

I saw the Hip three times on this tour, and I got three completely different shows. That's good enough for me. Like Sean pointed out, some of the recent setlists have been incredible.
Reply
#22

BRoach Wrote:
spottrax Wrote:Thats quite a list! If you count all the covers, they've played probably around 125 songs total this tour. Other than Pearl Jam, I cant think of another band that does that many different songs in a single tour!

you don't listen to jam bands :mrgreen:

gov't mule, tea leaf green, phil lesh...
these bands will do 3-4 night runs without repeating 1 song

not that the hip don't mix it up...because they do! (just not enough)

when i saw gov't mule @ the kool haus [Dec 1, 2005 + Dec 1, 2006] they only repeated 1 song from the previous show (and they only repeated it, since they had the guy who composed the song guest with them on stage)
42 different songs out of 43 songs played....
that's what i call mixing it up


I actually never thought of the Hip as a jam band....ie Govnt Mule, Dead, Phish, Tea Leaf....etc...

Yes, the Hip had some serious jams back in the DFN, TATHH and PP tours but their extended jams were usually in the same songs...ie...New O, Meridian, Grace...etc.

Everyone is entitled to their opinions about their tastes in musical experiences but I've always regarded the Hip as simply an amped up folk band. Some of those jams (as with nowdays in Meridian) are just an added bonus for both the band and the fans at live shows.... :thumb:
Reply
#23

spottrax Wrote:
BRoach Wrote:
spottrax Wrote:Thats quite a list! If you count all the covers, they've played probably around 125 songs total this tour. Other than Pearl Jam, I cant think of another band that does that many different songs in a single tour!

you don't listen to jam bands :mrgreen:

gov't mule, tea leaf green, phil lesh...
these bands will do 3-4 night runs without repeating 1 song

not that the hip don't mix it up...because they do! (just not enough)

when i saw gov't mule @ the kool haus [Dec 1, 2005 + Dec 1, 2006] they only repeated 1 song from the previous show (and they only repeated it, since they had the guy who composed the song guest with them on stage)
42 different songs out of 43 songs played....
that's what i call mixing it up


I actually never thought of the Hip as a jam band....ie Govnt Mule, Dead, Phish, Tea Leaf....etc...

Yes, the Hip had some serious jams back in the DFN, TATHH and PP tours but their extended jams were usually in the same songs...ie...New O, Meridian, Grace...etc.

Everyone is entitled to their opinions about their tastes in musical experiences but I've always regarded the Hip as simply an amped up folk band. Some of those jams (as with nowdays in Meridian) are just an added bonus for both the band and the fans at live shows.... :thumb:

i didnt necessarily mean jam band in terms of playing a 20+ minute song..
just pointing out that jam bands are known for heavy duty setlist variety

i see where you're coming from though
i like it when the hip do extended jams, but i'm not sure a 20 minute coconut cream would get the fans going..
Reply
#24

Having seen the Dead 50+ times I can tell you that fans used to bitch about them as well. It' insane. I mean if they came out and played WC in it's entirety someone would bitch. The Dead were the same in a way, they have so many songs to pick from.

Example. I am a huge Rush fan, but if you go see them one night, and then see them a month later...you will see the same show, front to back. That is not a dig at Rush, but it is the reality.

The way I see it, if the guys are having fun, so am I. Wow, it is actually Thursday, which means today I am seeing the Hip, 7-th row in the Cuse'. My wife made the comment that Gord could sing "Mary Had A Little Lamb", and I would look at her and say, deep, listen to how he sung that...LOL. Back to my point, the set lists are what they are. Most of you here have seen the Hip far more that the "average" fan. While I am far from an average fan, I have not seen them 50-100 times.

Lurked here for too long without joining. Glad to finally be part of the community. :thumb:

I will be sure to report on the Cuse show for those are interested.

One more thing on the original topic that might make some sense. I recall The Dead playing "Throwin' Stones" one night, and then played it again two nights later. Many 'Head' were like that is lame, etc...but, if you listen to the tapes, they worked on some different things, or did not like the version from the previous show, whatever....Boys deserve a rest....cannot wait to share in one of the last of this year....

CU in Kingston in Feb??!! :thumb: :jump
Reply
#25

Okay, at which show did they play The Dark Canuck?

EDIT: Never mind. I found it.
Reply
#26

[quote="sean.bonner"]I wouldn't call 'Put It Off', 'Eldorado', 'The Dark Canuck', 'Chagrin Falls', and 'Opiated' standard by any means...
Iquote]

great post Sean..

I agree 100%..

the fan base is getting a little spoiled I say..

try following U2 or the Who for a while and see what lack of variety they bring to each show... yet no one complains (myself included)..

The Hip will be going into a long hibernation now and these some donkeys will be complaining about the lack of any "tour dates"..

Some people will never be satisfied...

Last comment:

Friggin "Fiddler's Green" people!!!!!

They could come out, play that song, and say "thanks.. goodnight" and that would be worth thr price of admission..

How long has it been since that song was recorded with zero live performances???

Seeing History being made here folks!

Scott in Boston
Reply
#27

i just wish gord would stop repeating the same rants as if we've never heard them before.

remember 1992/1993? bearded gordo sure pulled out the stops then... but then again hallucinogens will do that to ya.
Reply
#28

RevolutionMan Wrote:i just wish gord would stop repeating the same rants as if we've never heard them before.

remember 1992/1993? bearded gordo sure pulled out the stops then... but then again hallucinogens will do that to ya.
Confusedhock: :rambo: :rambo:
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)