[FighterAndLover]

I guess my problem lies in the fact that I don't know how much attention each song receives.

Setlists:
http://www.hipbase.com/stats/songs.php?s...d=&set_id=

'Yer Favourites' selections:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yer_Favourites

Fan posts/polls:
http://hipbase.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7994

I think we've explained this though, so if you don't get it feel free to avoid the thread.

[tigerthelion]

I guess my problem lies in the fact that I don't know how much attention each song receives.

Setlists:
http://www.hipbase.com/stats/songs.php?s...d=&set_id=

'Yer Favourites' selections:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yer_Favourites

Fan posts/polls:
http://hipbase.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=7994

I think we've explained this though, so if you don't get it feel free to avoid the thread.

On hipbase, 'Courage' is underrated if anything. A setlist has nothing to do with the fans opinions of the songs btw. :thumb:

You didn't explain jackshit. Skippy explained it but .....whatever.....to each his own. Enjoy the thread. I'm glad that people get upset when other people use their brain. :rambo: These lists are so gosh darn fun, they really are.

Here's my answer to this topic:

I don't consider any songs underrated or overrated. Since this is my subjective opinion, it's impossible for you question it or say it's wrong.

[opiated]

I SAY MORE FIONA!!!! I SAY MORE NORAH!!!!!

[u8555]

I don't consider any songs underrated or overrated. Since this is my subjective opinion, it's impossible for you question it or say it's wrong.

wrong

[opiated]

I don't consider any songs underrated or overrated. Since this is my subjective opinion, it's impossible for you question it or say it's wrong.

wrong

no..you're wrong

[zopust]

Ok, what about "Under-appreciated" as in, most people don't appreciate "The Bear" as being a truly great song, one which deserves more mentions than it gets...

[opiated]

how 'bout listen to the songs you like, don't listen to the ones you dislike?

[u8555]

[quote="opiatedno..you're wrong[/quote]

no...you're wrong (joking my friend).

[opiated]

[quote="opiatedno..you're wrong

no...you're wrong (joking my friend).[/quote]

i see no Norah Jones or Fiona Apple in your posts..you are wrong!!!

[Janie]

i see no Norah Jones or Fiona Apple in your posts..you are wrong!!!

That's because they are both overrated in my opinion.

[Zenith]

Ok, what about "Under-appreciated" as in, most people don't appreciate "The Bear" as being a truly great song, one which deserves more mentions than it gets...

Absolutely! :thumb: (Consider this another mention for it )

[Daryl24]

No, your a towel...

[Chris Tanz]

No, your a towel...

oh towelie, you're the worst character ever.

ct

[skippy the wonder dog]

how 'bout listen to the songs you like, don't listen to the ones you dislike?

Just whatever you do, don't discuss what you like or don't like.

Least of all on a board called "Tragically Hip Discussion."

[tragicallysteve]

how 'bout listen to the songs you like, don't listen to the ones you dislike?

Just whatever you do, don't discuss what you like or don't like.

Least of all on a board called "Tragically Hip Discussion."

And if you're going to discuss what you like and don't like, make sure everyone has the exact same opinion as you.

We need rules and structure, people!!!