Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

Bob Rock Producing Next Album
#46

The Darkest Canuck Wrote:of course i'm excited for new hip! i think all of us are, we're just concerned that Rock might lead the boys astray...i'll give you this though, i'm quite interested to see how this turns out...

Maybe that could be a good thing, get them thinking outside the box a bit.
Reply
#47

Good joke guys, haha! Bob Rock producing the hip! I almost fell for it.

Seriously folks, I am worried. I hold the hip up as one of the most artistically credible bands around. I compare them to all other bands for that. If they come out with their own version of OLP's "gravity" I am going to just freak out.
Reply
#48

sfissel Wrote:Good joke guys, haha! Bob Rock producing the hip! I almost fell for it.

Seriously folks, I am worried. I hold the hip up as one of the most artistically credible bands around. I compare them to all other bands for that. If they come out with their own version of OLP's "gravity" I am going to just freak out.
It will never happen, chill out. Once this album drops all your fears will be put to rest. So let it be written, so let it be done!

The Lizard King wouldn't lie to you. :wink:

Imagine a world before the "beginning was the word.”
Reply
#49

Did Bob Rock have anything to do with "No Threat"? Excuse me if I'm behind on the times but I'm not sure. I assumed Kasper was involved with the song. It is a heavier song than I'm used to the Hip making. I'm just wondering if Bob Rock had any influence on the song. BTW, I like "No Threat". I just hope that the Hip don't turn radio friendly like the songs from OLP's Gravity and all Simple Plan songs.
Reply
#50

You can say what you want about Bob Rock everybody, but look what he does.....He is a gifted music producer and musician ( remember Rock and Hyde, of The Payolas)
He also puts money in the bands' pockets that he produces. Something that The Hip hasn't seen in a long while..don't get me wrong people, I LOVE The Hip, the album sales just haven't been there in several years.
Maybe, just maybe, Bob Rock is the ticket to crack the States.
Just my opinion.........
Reply
#51

kennedy11 Wrote:Maybe, just maybe, Bob Rock is the ticket to crack the States.
Just my opinion.........

and.....SCENE!
Reply
#52

kennedy11 Wrote:You can say what you want about Bob Rock everybody, but look what he does.....He is a gifted music producer and musician ( remember Rock and Hyde, of The Payolas)
He also puts money in the bands' pockets that he produces. Something that The Hip hasn't seen in a long while..don't get me wrong people, I LOVE The Hip, the album sales just haven't been there in several years.
Maybe, just maybe, Bob Rock is the ticket to crack the States.
Just my opinion.........


If the Hip were gonna crack the States, it would've happened a long time ago. I still say 1996 should have been their year. "Ahead by a Century" was a sure-fire smash hit. That tune is one of the most perfectly crafted pop songs in rock n' roll history, and in a perfect world it should've catapulted them into the stratosphere. Why it didn't is beyond me. Bob Rock can polish off their edges and slick 'em up as much as he wants, but it ain't gonna change their fortunes in the States. If you look at what's currently popular in mainstream American music, the Hip are about as far from it as you can possibly get. No amount of studio trickery is gonna change that, and I seriously doubt the Hip would allow Rock to screw with their sound that much anyway (at least I hope not...yikes, just thinking about that scares the hell out of me).
Reply
#53

I just wanted to let everyone know that I'm still panicky about this. I'm surprised this thread isn't at page 10 already.

I told my friend about it, his response: "maybe the hip lost a bet".

I really want this album to be good.
Reply
#54

sfissel Wrote:I just wanted to let everyone know that I'm still panicky about this. I'm surprised this thread isn't at page 10 already.

I told my friend about it, his response: "maybe the hip lost a bet".


Haha! I was thinking the same thing. I'm still worried as well. Over the past few days I've been trying to think of the positives that could come from this situation, and unfortunately there aren't too many. I'd like to think that the Hip are such a great band that not even Bob Rock ccould make them sound shitty. I certainly hope that's the case. From what MAv has told us, Gord Downie has been very happy with the recording so far, and that's definitely a good sign (I hope). Maybe Adam Kasper can find a way to hijack the proceedings and co-produce the album.
Reply
#55

I was hoping this album would be the 1 where the did the producing themselves again.....

I will not give up. My face is set,my gait is fast,my goal is heaven,my road is narrow,my way is rough,my companions are few,my guide is reliable,my mission is clear. I cannot be bought,compromised,detoured,lured away,turned back,diluted or delayed. I will not flinch in the face of sacrifice,hesitate in the presence of adversity,negotiate at the table of the enemy,ponder at the pool of popularity,or meander in the maze of mediocrity. I will not give up,shut up or slow down....Blessed Be!
Reply
#56

Summiteer Wrote:I was hoping this album would be the 1 where the did the producing themselves again.....
They have produced there own album before. TATHH I do believe.

Its actually none of our business who they choose really. They can do whatever they want. Celine Dions husband could produce it as far as I am concerned. The Hip is the Hip it will be good no matter what.
Reply
#57

Oh God. The new album is a sure bet to suck rocks. (no pun intended).

Don't get me wrong, I'm sure the material---as in the songs themselves---will be fine. But this record, like IVL and FC, is sure to sound awful, sapped of energy, *polished* (i.e., crap). And the worst part of it is, this comes after the Hip's best record in years...it risks robbing them of a chance to build on the ears perked up by IBE.

Nor do the Hip have a good track record of defeating bad producers: IVL and FC are both blots, sonically-speaking.

Oh, well. All my arguments to the fallen, former Hip fans, that the Hop are still a hungry-sounding, urgent, muscular band (based on IBE) will be in ruins. Balls.
Reply
#58

Killer Whale Tank Wrote:Don't get me wrong, I'm sure the material---as in the songs themselves---will be fine. But this record, like IVL and FC, is sure to sound awful, sapped of energy, *polished* (i.e., crap). And the worst part of it is, this comes after the Hip's best record in years...it risks robbing them of a chance to build on the ears perked up by IBE.
I can't imagine there are many people out there, devoted fans or not, that would prefer IBE 2 to FC 2.

I would wager that at a typical Hip concert 10 000 of the people present would consider FC one of the Hip's 2 best albums.
Reply
#59

Killer Whale Tank Wrote:Oh, well. All my arguments to the fallen, former Hip fans, that the Hop are still a hungry-sounding, urgent, muscular band....

So you try to get them out to shows by saying, "Let's go to the Hop, oh baby, let's go to the Hop?"

"Cos I'm thinking that might be part of the problem. Smile
Reply
#60

Killer Whale Tank Wrote:Oh God. The new album is a sure bet to suck rocks. (no pun intended).

Don't get me wrong, I'm sure the material---as in the songs themselves---will be fine. But this record, like IVL and FC, is sure to sound awful, sapped of energy, *polished* (i.e., crap). And the worst part of it is, this comes after the Hip's best record in years...it risks robbing them of a chance to build on the ears perked up by IBE.

Nor do the Hip have a good track record of defeating bad producers: IVL and FC are both blots, sonically-speaking.

Oh, well. All my arguments to the fallen, former Hip fans, that the Hop are still a hungry-sounding, urgent, muscular band (based on IBE) will be in ruins. Balls.

I agree. This album sounds terrible. The Hip have certainly tumbled a long way since 2004's In Between Evolution. This latest effort has been completely ruined by Bob Rock's production.

I'm kidding with you obviously: I also hope they don't make another dog like Fully Completely. There are barely a half-dozen songs on that twelve-song album that any sane person would consider as some of their best work.

(And what's so bad about songs sounding "polished". Some of my best friends are Polish.)

ct
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)