[daysleeperchuk]

theres a great graphic on the web site for the jack black movie"school of rock" which shows the blackboard they used in the movie--with the "family tree" style work up of the history of rock and roll --its cool.--i think its <!-- w --><a class="postlink" href="http://www.schoolofrock.com">www.schoolofrock.com</a><!-- w --> or do a google for the official movie web site.--i dont know how to do tricks or else id post it.--by the way--- beatles--led zeppelin--rollling stones ----bob dylan----pink floyd--the who---the clash--u2---the doors----r.e.m.--radiohead---tragically hip---pearl jam--stevie ray vaughn--talking heads----tom petty----and the heartbreakers(duh)--the grateful dead----the smiths----the verve!----the band----van freakin morrison!--bob marley and the wailers---theres just too much good music --but that my standing order as of today.

[lord brazle]

The Hip are my fave - the only band I actually post on a forum about and manage a site dedicated to. The Rolling Stones and The Doors have been long-time faves too. I wouldn't call myself "die-hard" but I know the majority of the songs. I was never big on Zeppelin or The Who or The Beatles. I'm probably one of the few guys in the world who actually hate The Beatles. Aerosmith's also a long-time fave; since I was like 9 or 10 I've been belting out Big Ones. lol. And Kid Rock. I started listening to him in 96 and I own every album but he's not a band so forget I mentioned him.

:thumb:

[jen]

Why no Pink Floyd?? Just curious...

My fav band of all time is DMB with Hip and Floyd a close 2nd

[Motherless Child]

wow thats the worst list of choices.... only ONE of those bands should be in the top 3 or so... and thats zepp

most overrated band ever: the beattles...

I am a HUGE hip fan but they aren't even the best band in canadian history... that would be The Band

that being said... grateful dead, allman brothers, the talking heads, zepplin, the band, beach boys, band of gypsy's, cream, the wailers.... etc ...ANY miles davis grouping .... those were the best bands ever..... the rest on that list just don't match up


IMO the grateful dead, talking heads, allmans, zepp, the band, and band of gypsy's were the best of the best.... and only those should be the choices

[intothenight]

The only bands that belong on that list are The Beatles and Led Zeppelin.

Both very influential. . . although Beatles were more versatile. . far more versatile

At the same time every member of Led Zeppelin was a thousand times more musically talented than every member in the beatles.

[srb]

I think the Velvet Underground could have taken on any of the bands listed in the poll!

[Killer Whale Tank]

U2 definitely deserves mention. Their influence is immense, from Radiohead on out (that Yorke guy sings JUST like Bono, as does half the singers coming out of the UK these days).

Beatles, overrated?? There's one in every crowd. They're the hands-down winner in ANY such competition, or should be. :thumb:

Surprised no one seems to be voting Stones, given their influence on the Hip and all.

[Lizard King]

LOL, this is awesome, I love a heated debate. I knew Id catch hell for leaving some bands on or off, I just put it together for fun, I broke my ribs yesterday so Im sitting here in pain just goofing around.....Ill do better next time I promise!

[skippy the wonder dog]

To paraphrase Master Yoda: there is no best, only do. Or, to paraphrase another great thinker, there's no point in bull meese comparing their racks. This is the error of catalogues and lists.

Seriously, any attempt to say which band is "best" is doomed to failure. Best by what standard? Most innovative? Most influential? Most original? Most obnoxious to parents?

[lord brazle]

The eye of the beholder, Skippy :thumb:

[skippy the wonder dog]

That's my problem, Brazle. I just can't make up my mind.

[thipfan73]

Even if I think the Beatles are so much a cliche, I still voted for them because they started a revolution. If it wasn't for them we wouldn't have the other bands who are listed in the poll.

You say you want a revolution?
Well you know
We all want to change the world.

I think the greatest rock and roll performer of all time is Elvis. They say either you're a Beatles fan or an Elvis fan. I'm an Elvis fan. I think that would be a great poll!!!

*goes to make poll in non hip*

[prz]

i think its the beatles

[The Darkest Canuck]

Pink Floyd...


and you didn't even put them as an option



FOR SHAME!

[The Darkest Canuck]

also, Tenacious D should get an honourable mention in here :mrgreen: