Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

What is the one song that has eluded you??
#46

Jenna_Bird Wrote:
The Horrible Esthete Wrote:Leave is one of my favorites, and I got to hear it (in Cleveland, I think) but didn't feel it came off too well. There's alot of 'studio treatment' on that track which, for me I guess, creates some of the great mood and atmosphere of that song which of course couldn't be duplicated onstage. And to me, it came off sounding a little disjointed and unfocused.

According to the massive song list on the 'base, it was played in Buffalo, Detroit, New York and Toronto. Did you see them in Detroit in '02, perhaps?

-Jenna

It certainly wasn't Detroit, as I think that was one of those "warmup" shows for the IVL tour that you had to win tickets to.

I thought for sure I saw it in Cleveland. I would've sworn they played it one of the back-to-back nights they did at the Odeon in late Aug, 2002. Apparently I'm wrong ....that's the only drawback to hitting nearly 50 of one band's shows -- the memory simply cannot be completely trusted.
As I've said, that database is missing alot of early shows / setlists, but seems rather complete for more recent history, and since they've apparently only played Leave 4 times (and only in warmup shows), I think it's safe to say that I'm full crap on that.

:oops:

I wonder what I'm thinking of? I'm probably remembering that the bootleg of the Magic Studios (Buffalo) warmup where they play IVL in its entirety, and I'm associating that with those IVL dates in Cleveland?
Reply
#47

The Horrible Esthete Wrote:Leave is one of my favorites, and I got to hear it (in Cleveland, I think) but didn't feel it came off too well. There's alot of 'studio treatment' on that track which, for me I guess, creates some of the great mood and atmosphere of that song which of course couldn't be duplicated onstage. And to me, it came off sounding a little disjointed and unfocused.
Well, since you brought it up - let's all listen to it again.
I have actually been lucky enough to see this song live twice.

Leave: <!-- w --><a class="postlink" href="http://www.angelfire.com/blues/tthdana/leave.mp3">www.angelfire.com/blues/tthdana/leave.mp3</a><!-- w --> (right click and "save as")
Toronto, ON - Club 279 - IVL premiere broadcast 6-12-2

"We're forced to bed, but we're free to dream"
Dana
Reply
#48

How did you manage to see it twice of the four times they've played it? Wow. Lucky you.

What did you think of the live renditions?

I can't listen to that recording until I get home, but I'll certainly check it out then....
Reply
#49

Tthip Wrote:
The Horrible Esthete Wrote:Leave is one of my favorites, and I got to hear it (in Cleveland, I think) but didn't feel it came off too well. There's alot of 'studio treatment' on that track which, for me I guess, creates some of the great mood and atmosphere of that song which of course couldn't be duplicated onstage. And to me, it came off sounding a little disjointed and unfocused.
Well, since you brought it up - let's all listen to it again.
I have actually been lucky enough to see this song live twice.

Leave: <!-- w --><a class="postlink" href="http://www.angelfire.com/blues/tthdana/leave.mp3">www.angelfire.com/blues/tthdana/leave.mp3</a><!-- w --> (right click and "save as")
Toronto, ON - Club 279 - IVL premiere broadcast 6-12-2

Sounds awesome.Any chance of this show being shared on the tracker?
Reply
#50

The Horrible Esthete Wrote:How did you manage to see it twice of the four times they've played it? Wow. Lucky you.

What did you think of the live renditions?
Oops - I was mistaken - I only saw it once and that is the recording I posted.
It was on the setlist and Hipbase concert archive lists it as being played for 6-27-2 NYC show which I attended, but the encore was changed and they played Dark Canuck instead.
I am not too sure on my thoughts on the live version - the single time that I heard it was about the day the album was released and no one was very familiar with the new songs yet. So I was just thrilled I was hearing the whole album live.

"We're forced to bed, but we're free to dream"
Dana
Reply
#51

Yeah....unless I wasn't mistaken and did see it performed somewhere after all, the only live version I've heard was the Audio Magic Studios (buffalo) rendition, which sounds very unpolished and flat to me. But that's not a knock, really, as it was second time it was ever performed publicly.

So they didn't play it at the Irving Plaza show in June '02? That means that aside from those IVL premiere radio shows / warmups, they've never done it live. I guess they must've realized that it was going to be a tough one to do onstage......
Reply
#52

No Threat!
Smalltown Bringdown!
Reply
#53

The Bear was done in soundcheck, I used to have it on cassette...

I think I can say with an air of certainty that I'm probably the only one on the board who has seen Montreal performed live twice Wink
Reply
#54

I have not seen anyone mention one of all my all time favorites and that is ALL TORE UP. I have not yet been lucky enough to hear that one with 15 shows and counting!

Hopefully someday

"drink up folks it's getting on time to close" :music
Reply
#55

Thanks to the glorious club tour of 06 and the summer tour that preceded it, I got to hear songs I never imagined I would ever hear live, including;

Something On, Dire Wolf, Titanic Terrarium, Use it Up, Are You Ready, Lionized, Eldorado, The Rules, Chagrin Falls, Thirty-Eight Years Old, Putting Down, Sherpa, The Wherewithal, Greasy Jungle, We'll Go Too, So Hard Done By, Yawning or Snarling, Tiger the Lion, Save the Planet and Three Pistols
Reply
#56

^I was thinking the other day how fortunate I was to hear 'We'll Go Too' and 'Lionized' in London in '06 (even if I didn't really appreciate them at the time). I was watching the Utrecht DVD last night - Now that is a show I'd have loved to have been at! Amazing setlist! That certainly is a good list you racked up there.

SRK Wrote:I had a long-standing problem getting to see 'locked in the trunk of a car', which is my favourite hip song. If I went to a show, it'd be played the night before or the night after. It was even on the setlist for the first show I ever saw as the final song in the encore, but they called an audible and played little bones instead. So naturally I was thrilled in montreal at the first club show when that drum pattern kicked in and Gord said "this might be the only song ever dedicated to dostoevsky, but this is for dostoevsky. This is locked in the trunk of a car." I think I jumped about 4 feet in the air. And now they've played it at 3 of the last four shows I've seen. Go figure.

I was never much of a fan of Locked... until I saw it live in Amsterdam last year - It was incredible! Definitely a song that benefits from being heard live.
Reply
#57

LizardKing51 Wrote:
sean.bonner Wrote:I would do anything to see Emperor Penguin.

I know that if they ever started playing it at a show I was at... I would definetly get emotional. I don't care. It would be the pinnacle of my "fanship" for The Hip.

What that song means to be is indescribable.

..let me guess you got drunk and wiped your ass with your sleeve?

that's a physical impossibility...a physical impossibilium, a true impossiblium of pure impossibility, an impossible impossobilium, impossibly impossible, but hey, you know what they say...anything is possible...THAT'S IMPOSSIBLE!!!!!!!!!! How did you know that I was thinking of that number? is it even possible to count that high...from way down, so very far below...under the overcast, overtly overhung umbrella of clouds? imposing it's impossible impending impetus, immanently endangering us all? what were the odds of that happening?!?!?!?! fat chance, slim chance, none at all, not a chance in hell...it was a physicallllllllllllllllllllllllll impossibility!


hehe, thought i'd try my hand at a little rant...after doing so, i now have MUCH more respect for Gord's rants, it ain't easy bein G.D.!
Reply
#58

Opiated eluded me for a long time, and I like you am close to 30 shows. Kingston was my 28th. Opiated eluded me for many years...It has always been on my favourite songs for it's punchiness and rythm. When Gord and crew started belting it out I went to another place........a happier place........a greener place. That's that.
Reply
#59

Emperor Penguin gets my vote too. There are others, but this song would totally stand out for me.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)