PunBB
Greatest Double Album - Printable Version

+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Non Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=9)
+--- Thread: Greatest Double Album (/showthread.php?tid=5518)

Pages: 1 2

Greatest Double Album - opiated - 02-22-2005

my vote would either go to the white album (beatles) or physical graffiti..zeppelin...both have such strange, brilliant tracks on them..like

white album: happiness is a warm gun, blackbird, sexy sadie, yer blues, glass onion.....

P.G.: Kashmir, Black Country Woman..(love the acoustic live feel to this..this is zeppelin at its finest..having a blast!!), down by the seaside, in the light, sick again....

ok..it's a tie!!!

special mention to (yes.i'm not afraid to admit it..) elton johns goodbye yellow brick road

Re: Greatest Double Album - LastStop - 02-22-2005

I've had this discussion with a friend before. My personal favorite double album would be Pink Floyd - The Wall, but I certainly can't argue with your choices. Another fav of mine is Mellon Collie & The Infinite Sadness.

I wish more bands would release double albums.

- opiated - 02-22-2005

ahh.yes..the wall..love it, especially if i feel like bringing myself down!! a classic..and i'd forgotten about the pumpkins cd(shame on me)..think i'll throw that in now...the thing i love about double discs, is the "obscure" tracks that normally wouldn't make an album..for me on the s.p. disc, it's lily!!! love that track!!

- emperor penguin - 02-22-2005

how about houses of the holy, bron-yr-aur, trampled underfoot and in my time of dying, from physical graffiti, 4 great tunes. Wow was that ever a great album. bron-yr-aur is probably the best display of acoustic guitar playing i've ever heard. and on a sidenote one of the coolest covers i've ever seen, i have the cd case that looks like the vinyl case and i love how you can remove the insert to reveal different pictures thgrough the windows.

- direwolf74 - 02-22-2005

There's no question the albums mentioned so far are classics, but personally I'm gonna have to go with something a little more recent: Being There by Wilco. Easily one of the most brilliant records I've ever had the pleasure of listening to.

- The Darkest Canuck - 02-22-2005

more goodies:

Nine Inch Nails-The Fragile (a masterpiece, this album never gets the props it deserves)

Metallica-Garage Inc. (quite possibly the last worthwhile studio offering they'll ever offer up)

Cypress Hill-Skull & Bones (think about it: most rap artists have a hard time putting together one album of decent material, The Hill put out a rock solid double LP, possibly the best release of their career, a modern day hip-hop classic)

Ozzy-Live And Loud

Black Sabbath-Reunion (i dunno about everyone else, but hearing the original masters of reality play their first show in so many years in front of a sould-out hometown crowd makes my spine tingle, not to mention the 2nd disc has their two first studio recordings since the 70's on it too)

Pink Floyd-Pulse

Pink Floyd-Ummagumma (some of the strangest songs ever recorded are on this album, the live disc is killer too)

- NMAS - 02-22-2005

Wilco- Being There would be my choice at this time.

- Lizard King - 02-22-2005

I totally agree with the Led Zep choice for number 1, as for others, not really studio double albums, but I like Neil Young's "Decade" double disc and Oasis' double live "Familiar to Millions" and Mellencamps "Words & Music" all really good too.

Re: Greatest Double Album - The Horrible Esthete - 02-22-2005

LastStop Wrote:My personal favorite double album would be Pink Floyd - The Wall, but I certainly can't argue with your choices. Another fav of mine is Mellon Collie & The Infinite Sadness.

No love for Decade? Or is it just that it is a compilation of previously-released material? Great DD, nonetheless.

Personally, I second the three greats already listed:

1. Physical Graffiti
2. The Wall
3. The White ALbum


emporer penguin Wrote:how about houses of the holy, bron-yr-aur, trampled underfoot and in my time of dying, from physical graffiti, 4 great tunes.

Not to mention In the Light, Ten Years Gone, The Rover, and Night Flight? And the others - hell, this could be the greatest album ever.

emporer penguin Wrote:bron-yr-aur is probably the best display of acoustic guitar playing i've ever heard

Agreed. First of all, Jimmy's engineering / production is incredible - given that Bron-yr-aur was recorded in the sixties , it sounds absolutely terrific. The resonation of that jumbo Martin he recorded that on is marvelous. Secondly, the composition itself is so brilliant that it dumbfounds the common hack like myself. Page often uses non-standard tunings, and this song is no exception - it’s in the DADGAD tuning he loves to use, (I think). When a friend (and cousin) played it for me recently, I was moved nearly to tears - not because I was so awed by his rendition (which seemed flawless), but because of how beautifully seamless the composition is in itself. The progression is simple and logical - somber, yet somehow strangely uplifting at the same time.

“Genius” is the word.....

Re: Greatest Double Album - opiated - 02-22-2005

emporer penguin Wrote:ote="emporer penguin"]bron-yr-aur is probably the best display of acoustic guitar playing i've ever heard

Agreed. First of all, Jimmy's engineering / production is incredible - given that Bron-yr-aur was recorded in the sixties , it sounds absolutely terrific. The resonation of that jumbo Martin he recorded that on is marvelous. Secondly, the composition itself is so brilliant that it dumbfounds the common hack like myself. Page often uses non-standard tunings, and this song is no exception - it’s in the DADGAD tuning he loves to use, (I think). When a friend (and cousin) played it for me recently, I was moved nearly to tears - not because I was so awed by his rendition (which seemed flawless), but because of how beautifully seamless the composition is in itself. The progression is simple and logical - somber, yet somehow strangely uplifting at the same time.

“Genius” is the word.....[/quote]


seen the movie song remains the same? when they're in the limo and this song is playing...genius is indeed the word, and yes the more i think about it, physical graffiti is the best album EVER

- Hairbird - 02-22-2005

Exile On Main Street

greatest double album - cochise - 02-22-2005

Well the top two in no order (don't ask me to put one above the other!)

1. Stones - Exile On Main Street
2. Floyd - The Wall

Doesn't get any better, period.

- Lizard King - 02-22-2005

am I the only one having problems viewing the last 2 posts in this thread?? the screen is all fucked and shifted..

- thipfan73 - 02-22-2005

Yep, it's all fucked up.

I vote for the wall

- joshwayy - 02-23-2005

I think Kirk Cameron was unhappy we were talking about Jimmy Page- he's a devil worshiper! you know- and he screwed up the page alignment! lol

Physical Graffiti is a masterpiece. Many of those songs were unreleased from ealrlier albums. I've found a lot of zep shows on torrent sites and the 1975 shows from LA and NYC feature a lot of physical songs...the height of their prowess!

Live albums and compilations don't count...only original tunes. The wall is a close second in my opinion.