are they done? - Printable Version
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: are they done? (/showthread.php?tid=15295)
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: are they done? (/showthread.php?tid=15295)
are they done? - eatmecompletely - 01-13-2014
radio silence on any news from them
what is going on ?
Re: are they done? - sean.bonner - 01-13-2014
I'd assume writing / time off / other projects.
Re: are they done? - thebends - 01-13-2014
The band's approach to their ongoing relationship with their fans is increasingly disappointing. Especially at a time when social media is such a great enabler for stuff like this. Too bad.
Re: are they done? - Phildozer - 01-13-2014
Talk about disappointing.
I saw/heard some of the live recordings of last Summer's tour, particularly the show in Newfoundland. I hope Gord was just really drunk or on drugs because it was horrible. Absolutely horrible.
Re: are they done? - eatmecompletely - 01-13-2014
im not sure if its their management or they dont get it
i dont need a news flash about a $75 t shirt that looks like shit
would love to know what they are upto now?
not sure who is managing this band now or if they stoped caring about their fans
Re: are they done? - eatmecompletely - 01-13-2014
also the fact that fans are posting questions like
are they done?
Next steps ?
Where to go from here!
This board used to be such a bubble to fluff the hip
but i guess the band can only shit on their fans so much
Re: are they done? - direwolf74 - 01-13-2014
I don't think they're done, but they might as well be considering the state of things recently. So far the only band member we've heard from lately is Paul on his Facebook page. Granted it's all been updates about his solo record & tour, so nothing Hip related. But at least he's keeping fans up to speed. Seems like the rest of the guys have completely disappeared into their family lives, which is all well and good. I'm all for them taking some time off from the rock n' roll machine, but it would be nice if their management would at least give us a little update here and there. You know, like every other band on the planet does.
I did hear that the long-rumored Sadies/Downie collaboration is finally being released this year. Can't remember exactly where I read it, but I'm pretty sure that came straight from one of the guys in the Sadies. I wonder if they'll tour for that record. And will Gord actually use his natural singing voice if they do? The Sadies are consummate professionals, and I doubt they'd put up with Gord's screaming crap for an entire tour. It'll be interesting to see what happens when that album finally drops.
As for the Hip, I really hope they can come back and rediscover the magic again. As recently as 2009 I considered them the greatest rock n' roll band in the world. But unfortunately their stock has dropped considerably with the last couple of tours. I'd love to see them prove us all wrong and kick our asses once again.
Re: are they done? - fingernailsonhull - 01-14-2014
direwolf74 Wrote:I don't think they're done, but they might as well be considering the state of things recently. So far the only band member we've heard from lately is Paul on his Facebook page. Granted it's all been updates about his solo record & tour, so nothing Hip related. But at least he's keeping fans up to speed. Seems like the rest of the guys have completely disappeared into their family lives, which is all well and good. I'm all for them taking some time off from the rock n' roll machine, but it would be nice if their management would at least give us a little update here and there. You know, like every other band on the planet does.
I did hear that the long-rumored Sadies/Downie collaboration is finally being released this year. Can't remember exactly where I read it, but I'm pretty sure that came straight from one of the guys in the Sadies. I wonder if they'll tour for that record. And will Gord actually use his natural singing voice if they do? The Sadies are consummate professionals, and I doubt they'd put up with Gord's screaming crap for an entire tour. It'll be interesting to see what happens when that album finally drops.
As for the Hip, I really hope they can come back and rediscover the magic again. As recently as 2009 I considered them the greatest rock n' roll band in the world. But unfortunately their stock has dropped considerably with the last couple of tours. I'd love to see them prove us all wrong and kick our asses once again.
What he said.
Re: are they done? - ashtrayrock - 01-14-2014
i highly doubt it...probably just some much deserved time off from the big machine
i thought NFPA was a great cd, just not quite as good as the 2 bob rock ones.(IMO)
as long as they write good music i will be listening
my glass is way more than half full
Re: are they done? - cochise - 01-15-2014
I hope its just a bit of time off to get the train back on track. I don't want them to (or expect them to) make another Day For Night, but I sure miss the sound that made them The Hip and I keep hoping with each new album, they'll return to it.
I had such high hopes after In Between Evolution came out, I really thought they were on the path back, but then took a huge detour with everything since.
It reminds me a bit of Rush, in the 80's they lost their way a bit, but then "Presto" came out and you could hear them coming back to what made them Rush. After that album they returned more and more with each album without sounding like they were "remaking" any album............
I really thought In Between Evolution was their slow return, kinda like Presto was...................
Still crossing fingers though
Re: are they done? - Dark Canuck17 - 01-16-2014
I agree an update would be nice I mean what do they think Twitter is for...isn't Mav the one doing all there stuff anyway for social media where has he been? With that being said NFPA is only just over a year old, they are not going to pump out new material like the did in the early years...I will be happy if it is just sooner than my second favourite band U2...talk about a gap between albums with their last two!
Re: are they done? - direwolf74 - 01-16-2014
Dark Canuck17 Wrote:they are not going to pump out new material like the did in the early years...I will be happy if it is just sooner than my second favourite band U2...talk about a gap between albums with their last two!
When it comes to long gaps between albums for active bands, I think the Weakerthans hold the current world record. Their last album "Reunion Tour" was released way back in 2007. It's been 7 long years and still nothing from those guys in terms of new material. Not even a hint or an update on what's going on. For a while there I figured they had likely broken up, but then last summer they went out and played a bunch of shows. It's weird.
Re: are they done? - Rye - 01-18-2014
Dire Wolf - if memory serves me correct The Weakerthans played three shows last year.
There was a story in the Winnipeg Free Press a week or two ago about Stephen Carroll (guitar player in The Weakerthans) being named the director of a local music venue here in Winnipeg. His quote was something about The Weakerthans not being active right now and no plans for the future.
Regarding The Hip, I thought there was a story late 2013 about some small town festival in ON negotiating with them to play a festival this summer but it was too expensive. Anyways, if that's being discussed I'm sure it will be more of the same from The Hip this summer (boring festivals in boring venues with boring setlists). Is it my imagination or have they played more smaller cities in Canada over the past ten years? Maybe they feel like it's easier to trot out their greatest hits shows in places that don't see them that often, or haven't seen them before.
Re: are they done? - direwolf74 - 01-18-2014
Rye Wrote:Dire Wolf - if memory serves me correct The Weakerthans played three shows last year.
There was a story in the Winnipeg Free Press a week or two ago about Stephen Carroll (guitar player in The Weakerthans) being named the director of a local music venue here in Winnipeg. His quote was something about The Weakerthans not being active right now and no plans for the future..
That's a shame. They're such a great band.
Re: are they done? - Dark Canuck17 - 01-20-2014
I say we all hammer Twitter asking for any updates they do have 73.6k followers