Which is your favorite song on WATS - Printable Version
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: Which is your favorite song on WATS (/showthread.php?tid=12568)
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: Which is your favorite song on WATS (/showthread.php?tid=12568)
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - jtr101 - 04-07-2009
Joe Wrote:..... Now the Struggle Has a Name is a stinker. And Honey Please is barely passable.
I am right with you on this comment!
I am really liking Coffee Girl and Depression Suite as my favs thoguh!
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - GordsGal - 04-07-2009
VioletLite Wrote:Am I the only person who thinks the melody in 'Honey, please' sounds like 'Is she really going out with him?' by Joe Jackson??? Or am I officially crazy?????????cratch:
ha, I thought the same thing when I was listening to it in the car lol!
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - emperpenguin - 04-07-2009
jtr101 Wrote:I enjoy Struggle, so I am not with you....I think it leads perfectly into Depression SuiteJoe Wrote:..... Now the Struggle Has a Name is a stinker. And Honey Please is barely passable.
I am right with you on this comment!
I am really liking Coffee Girl and Depression Suite as my favs thoguh!
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - buffalorob - 04-07-2009
Speaking of "sounds like", how about The Exact Feeling intro sounding like Jaded by Aerosmith?
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - jtr101 - 04-07-2009
emperpenguin Wrote:jtr101 Wrote:I enjoy Struggle, so I am not with you....I think it leads perfectly into Depression SuiteJoe Wrote:..... Now the Struggle Has a Name is a stinker. And Honey Please is barely passable.
I am right with you on this comment!
I am really liking Coffee Girl and Depression Suite as my favs thoguh!
Not sure what it is...i'm sure like every other album though it will grow on me as i listen more and more. For me every Hip Album has a couple songs that it takes a little bit more time for me to enjoy.
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - thebends - 04-07-2009
I'm still experiencing exponential enjoyment growth on every listen. The Last Recluse seems to be surfacing as a favourite for now, but this will change - too many gems to definitively pick just one.
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - Chris Tanz - 04-07-2009
Anyone else think that the first lyrics on "Honey Please" should be: "You think you're gonna take her away, with your money and your cocaine ..."
I still haven't had a chance to get past the first two songs today!! This is frustrating!
ct
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - sadohert - 04-07-2009
After the first few listens Coffee Girl, The Last Recluse, Queen of the Furrows, and Depression Suite all stood out BIG TIME... but being forced to choose one at this very moment I went with Queen.
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - The Nth Degree - 04-08-2009
I'm loving the Depression Suite............it's minus 11 inside my kettle
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - deadparrot - 04-08-2009
I was all over Coffee Girl at first...but Depression is really growing on me. So fricken sweeping and awesome. I wasn't sure what to make of this album at first...but albums usually take a couple listens for me to grasp it. After listening over 10 times now...this album is a-fricken-mazing! They never cease to amaze me.
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - emperor penguin - 04-08-2009
buffalorob Wrote:Speaking of "sounds like", how about The Exact Feeling intro sounding like Jaded by Aerosmith?
haha I mentioned that in another thread, it sounds exactly like it.
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - esummers - 04-08-2009
The Last Recluse is amazing IMO. It stood out for me the most. I'm riding in along in my truck and as the song progressed my smile got bigger and bigger! I actually had CHILLS over this tune for the first time in many albums. "The Last Canada Goose......". I love the way Gord sings it.
The only part that's strange is the OOOOOOOO towards the end. I thought I was in a midevil dungeon or something. I would have prefered a ripping guitair solo from R.B. - That being said, I love it.
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - Edward_K - 04-08-2009
i chose Frozen in my Tracks...but it really changes as i had Queen and Depression at the top...also love exact feeling and Country Day!
wrt, those not enjoying the struggle has a name, i also did not enjoy very much and then it crossed over to a classic when i saw it live at the movie-ator.
in the long term, i am pretty sure that my fave will end up settling on Depression Suite.
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - Inch An Hour - 04-10-2009
I'm beginning to agree with those saying the "The Depression Suite" is the sleeper favourite, it takes some time to grow on you. However, current crown is still held by "Queen".
Re: Which is your favorite song on WATS - Mr. Lahey - 04-10-2009
It's almost a shame how great songs like Country Day and Morning Moon have only 3% and 6%. There are just too many to choose from.
Maybe we should make a new poll: "Which WATS song ISN'T fantastic?"
