Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

I've really got "friends in low places"
#1

Sad to say, I used to know this guy, Bronson Penasse..I used to go to school with him, maybe 2 months before the murder...

This was taken from thestar.com today..


Barbarism in an Orangeville field
Mom hears how son pleaded for his life


On April 18, 2002, in a field outside Orangeville, 16-year-old Robbie McLennan was sexually assaulted, punched, kicked, burned with cigarettes and struck with stones until he died.

A hushed Brampton courtroom heard these awful details yesterday as the prosecutor read out an agreed statement of facts — part of a guilty plea by one of three charged in the Orangeville teen's 2002 death.

The youth, who cannot be identified, was 16 at the time, the same age as Robbie.

Robbie pleaded for his life, the court heard, throughout the three hours of torture in a Caledon field that started on the evening of April 18 and ended about 1 a.m. the next morning. The reason for the attack, according to the statement: He laughed at a 20-year-old acquaintance who had had too much to drink.

Robbie's mother, Kathy Bradley, sat through yesterday's gut-wrenching hearing, she said, for her son's sake.

She and her family know there are many more days of similar testimony ahead. Two others charged with Robbie's death are still before the courts.

"I did it for Robbie," said Bradley, fighting back tears as she stood in the hallway outside courtroom 211. "There are some sick people in this world."

Moments earlier, Bradley and other family members listened as a 19-year-old Orangeville teen pleaded guilty to second-degree murder in the Superior Court of Justice for his role in the grisly killing.

Robbie's battered body was found on the afternoon of April 19, 2002 in a field in Caledon. Three people were arrested the same day and have remained in custody since then.

The teen who pleaded guilty yesterday was 16 at the time of the crime, so his identity remains protected by the Youth Criminal Justice Act. He will be sentenced Feb. 11 as a youth by Mr. Justice Bruce Durno, who convicted him yesterday after he pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder but guilty to second-degree murder.

"No matter what justice is given, it will never be enough," said Larry Rule, McLennan's stepfather. "It's been very tough. Robbie's 5 1/2-year-old brother can't understand why he's not coming home."

Two other accused, Bronson Penasse, 22, of Scarborough, and a girl, who was 16 at the time and is now 18, are still before the courts, charged with first-degree murder.

McLennan had laughed at Penasse after he vomited from too much alcohol.

The boy was sexually assaulted, punched, kicked and stoned with rocks, some as heavy as 12.7 kilograms, during the attack that lasted three hours, according to the agreed statement of facts read into the record yesterday by crown prosecutor Richard Schwarzl.

A pathologist determined McLennan died from blunt force head trauma but that the young man, who was known to friends as a "gentle giant" could have died from the kicks to his head or the stoning alone.

More than 40 distinct areas of injury were found on the body, and death ensued over a matter of hours, the court heard.

The convicted teen admitted in the agreed statement of facts that he held McLennan while the other two beat him and admitted he stood on McLennan's arms, preventing him from protecting himself, court heard. He also admitted to sexually assaulting him with a stick, and participating in the beating.

McLennan knew the convicted teen from school but had met the other two accused only about a week earlier.

McLennan was a student at Orangeville District Secondary School when he met Penasse and the girl on April 10, according to the statement. McLennan had been in an argument with his mother and decided to spend the night at the Out of The Cold youth shelter.

He returned home the next day but by then had struck up a friendship with Penasse and the girl, the court heard. The three of them worked as volunteers at the Orangeville campaign office of Josh Matlow, the Liberal candidate in the provincial election.

The court heard that McLennan was with the two on the afternoon of April 18 when they broke a gumball machine and stole money. The three then went to Smilin' Jacks bar, where Penasse consumed three beers and three shooters.

The convicted teen met McLennan and the two other accused at another bar later in the afternoon where Penasse again consumed alcohol, the court heard.

Penasse then purchased more alcohol from an LCBO store and the four of them went into a forested area in Caledon, just metres south of the Orangeville town limits.

The court heard that in the late evening of April 18, Penasse began to feel sick and asked the convicted teen to stick his fingers down his throat so he could vomit. When he did, McLennan laughed.

"Robbie laughing at Penasse angered him so much that Penasse began punching and kicking him," Schwarzl said. Penasse sexually abused Robbie repeatedly and forced him to perform sex acts on others.

"Robbie attempted to run away from the attacks," Schwarzl read. "(D)uring the attacks, Robbie pleaded for his life. He offered to say that he was hit by a car, and offered up his jacket but the attacks continued."

The court heard the female accused kicked McLennan so hard in the groin that she ruptured a testicle. She also stomped on his face with such force that it left a clear shoe impression on his forehead.

The court also heard that there were five distinct cigarette burns on McLennan's body, two on the right side of his neck, one on his right jaw line, one on his upper left back of his shoulder and one on the back of his left mid calf.

Two rocks with McLennan's blood on them, weighing nine and 12.7 kilograms, were found next to his body when Orangeville Police discovered him on April 19 after they received a tip.

McLennan's blood was also found on the convicted teen's shorts as well on his right shoe. Amylase, found in saliva, from McLennan was also discovered on the convicted teen's underwear, including one area which was mixed with the convicted teen's semen, the court heard.

Today at the entrance to Dragonfly Park in Orangeville stands a memorial for McLennan, where flowers encircle a pole marked with the murdered teen's name.
Reply
#2

That is probably the most disturbing thing I've ever read, and a strong argument for capital punishment.

1995-04-07 Toledo | 1996-06-29 Toledo | 1996-11-23 Detroit | 1998-08-22 Toledo | 1999-02-12 Auburn Hills |
1999-05-05 Grand Rapids | 1999-07-31 Clarkston | 1999-12-31 Toronto | 2000-01-01 Toronto |
2000-06-14 Pontiac | 2000-07-15 Clarkston | 2000-12-02 Detroit | 2002-08-31 Clarkston |
2004-09-18 Detroit | 2007-04-12 Detroit | 2009-05-29 Detroit | 2012-11-28 Detroit | 2016-08-08 London | 2016-08-16 Hamilton
Reply
#3

scottitude Wrote:That is probably the most disturbing thing I've ever read, and a strong argument for capital punishment.

Good Lord. No, it's not. Vengance solves and deters nothing. Reason over Passion. The arguments against CP are a million to one... but that's another thread... Merry Christmas. Smile

Sad story, perps need to go away, and if I were Crown, given the nature of the crime, I'd press for Dangerous Offender status so the lil' creeps names can be released and a LONG sentence is guaranteed.

And before the arguments start pouring in: the justice system is flawed, but it's reform that's needed not radical, reactionary and ineffective change like Capital Punishment.
Reply
#4

That is so sad. That must have been so hard for his family to listen to. I cannot understand how anyone can do that to another person.
Reply
#5

Those shit bags should fry! No room for reason when you torture someone to death just for kicks.
Reply
#6

That is just sickening. No matter how many incidents I read like this I just can't believe there are people out there who are capable of treating others that way.

This reminded me of an incident that happened here in Winnipeg about a week ago. This guy was walking home in the middle of the night and got jumped by a group of people at this house party. A girl standing outside the front door screamed that this guy had assaulted her the previous weekend. So a bunch of people started beating the crap out of this poor guy - stomping on his head, kicking him in the ribs, etc. The report specified that they were taking "running football kicks" to his body. Then they dragged his body over to a fence where they preceded to jump off of the fence onto to this guy. Then they threw him in a trunk of a car and slammed the trunk onto his head a few times. He kept going in and out of consciousness, pleading for his life and all they kept saying to him is "you're going to die tonight." He was then thrown onto the street and one of the girls got into a van and tried to run him over. But lucky for him we had just had a storm here and the roads were pure ice so he just slid under the van.
Finally, someone heard something (I don't know why it took that long) and called the cops.

The amazing thing is that this guy survived! He didn't even have any broken bones. All he needed was a few stitches and after some tests he was released from the hospital the next day. The cops said that when they found him he was almost unrecognizable. No broken bones, no internal bleeding, brain damage - nothing! I just find that amazing.

And do you want to know what the kicker is??? This guy was innocent - he never assaulted that chick...he didn't even know her. It
was a case of mistaken identity. And he was almost killed because of it.

All of the accused are in custody as we speak but with the way our court system is going nowadays - it is extremely unlikely that any of them will face any jail time at all.
Reply
#7

Douglas Wrote:Those shit bags should fry! No room for reason when you torture someone to death just for kicks.
The biggest argument against capital punishment is the inherent fallibility of the system. Although in a case like this, it would seem right, we CANNOT have capital punishment because of things like the fact that it's highly prejudicial towards minorities (all things being equal, a black man is much more likely to be sentenced to death than a white man) and because, as we have seen with Donald Marshall and David Milgaard, the system is sometimes WRONG.

I think it's not worth killing 1,000 vicious murderers if it means taking a SINGLE innocent life. And the margin of error in the system is a HELL of a lot higher than 1 in 1000.
Reply
#8

Sorry to bring such a bad artical around during the Christmas season..I'm just having trouble dealing with it. I am wondering what else I can do..A month after the incident, a cop came to my school and interviewed me about the guy (Penasse), and I told him how bad of a person he is...and all his other friends did as well...So hopefully he'll get some serious time..

I just wish there was something else I could do.
Reply
#9

Man that is absolutely frightening. I can't imagine what it would be like to know a cold-blooded killer that well... *shudder*.

Did he ever pull stuff like that at school before? Did he threaten you or friends of yours? I'm brimming with questions here...

Good luck dealing with this.
Reply
#10

There were a few times where we'd be hanging out, and somebody would look at him the wrong way, and he'd say something, put on the tough guy act...Nobody liked him..yet they were afraid of him..it was weird. My best friend in high school was dating him when I first got to the school..it was an image thing..being with a "bad guy" I guess. Let him stay at my house a few times..never stole from me or anything like that..

The fact that my ex girlfriend kicked the boy in the groin so bad that it ruptured a testicle...I'm glad I never saw that side of her. It's just so hard to believe she was involved.

If you have any questions, don't clog up the forum with this sad news, just PM me...thanks.
Reply
#11

o78 Wrote:That is just sickening. No matter how many incidents I read like this I just can't believe there are people out there who are capable of treating others that way.

This reminded me of an incident that happened here in Winnipeg about a week ago. This guy was walking home in the middle of the night and got jumped by a group of people at this house party. A girl standing outside the front door screamed that this guy had assaulted her the previous weekend. So a bunch of people started beating the crap out of this poor guy - stomping on his head, kicking him in the ribs, etc. The report specified that they were taking "running football kicks" to his body. Then they dragged his body over to a fence where they preceded to jump off of the fence onto to this guy. Then they threw him in a trunk of a car and slammed the trunk onto his head a few times. He kept going in and out of consciousness, pleading for his life and all they kept saying to him is "you're going to die tonight." He was then thrown onto the street and one of the girls got into a van and tried to run him over. But lucky for him we had just had a storm here and the roads were pure ice so he just slid under the van.
Finally, someone heard something (I don't know why it took that long) and called the cops.

The amazing thing is that this guy survived! He didn't even have any broken bones. All he needed was a few stitches and after some tests he was released from the hospital the next day. The cops said that when they found him he was almost unrecognizable. No broken bones, no internal bleeding, brain damage - nothing! I just find that amazing.

And do you want to know what the kicker is??? This guy was innocent - he never assaulted that chick...he didn't even know her. It
was a case of mistaken identity. And he was almost killed because of it.

All of the accused are in custody as we speak but with the way our court system is going nowadays - it is extremely unlikely that any of them will face any jail time at all.

How the hell did this guy not have any broken bones?? Holy crap! and why do you say the assailants won't get any prison time? Ye gods Confusedhock: Confusedhock:
Reply
#12

grooveless touque Wrote:
Douglas Wrote:Those shit bags should fry! No room for reason when you torture someone to death just for kicks.
The biggest argument against capital punishment is the inherent fallibility of the system. Although in a case like this, it would seem right, we CANNOT have capital punishment because of things like the fact that it's highly prejudicial towards minorities (all things being equal, a black man is much more likely to be sentenced to death than a white man) and because, as we have seen with Donald Marshall and David Milgaard, the system is sometimes WRONG.

I think it's not worth killing 1,000 vicious murderers if it means taking a SINGLE innocent life. And the margin of error in the system is a HELL of a lot higher than 1 in 1000.

I agree with everyhing you say. I always look at things like this and think what if that was my brother or Dad. The logical side of me knows your right but if something like this happened to someone I love I would want the fuckers dead!
Reply
#13

grooveless touque Wrote:
Douglas Wrote:Those shit bags should fry! No room for reason when you torture someone to death just for kicks.
The biggest argument against capital punishment is the inherent fallibility of the system. Although in a case like this, it would seem right, we CANNOT have capital punishment because of things like the fact that it's highly prejudicial towards minorities (all things being equal, a black man is much more likely to be sentenced to death than a white man) and because, as we have seen with Donald Marshall and David Milgaard, the system is sometimes WRONG.

I think it's not worth killing 1,000 vicious murderers if it means taking a SINGLE innocent life. And the margin of error in the system is a HELL of a lot higher than 1 in 1000.

If you want another example you should read "Redrum: The Innocent". It's about the wrongful conviction of Guy Paul Morin for killing the neighbors daughter. It's a perfect example of how corrupt the justice system can be. This guy never stood a chance - the cops thought he was guilty from the start just because he seemed a little "weird." So they built their entire case around making him look guilty. Thankfully he was exonerated and freed but still.... what if there was capital punishment here? Would they have found him not guilty in time? It may seem like a good idea (for sickos that prey on children, for example) but too many innocent people behind bars would be dead because of it. Too much corruption and shit going on within the system.
Reply
#14

Thehip21 Wrote:Sorry to bring such a bad artical around during the Christmas season..I'm just having trouble dealing with it. I am wondering what else I can do..A month after the incident, a cop came to my school and interviewed me about the guy (Penasse), and I told him how bad of a person he is...and all his other friends did as well...So hopefully he'll get some serious time..

I just wish there was something else I could do.

It sounds like you have done everything you can do. You gave the police all the information you could so hopefully these sick people will get what they deserve.
Reply
#15

VioletlightHeron Wrote:How the hell did this guy not have any broken bones?? Holy crap! and why do you say the assailants won't get any prison time? Ye gods Confusedhock: Confusedhock:

Nobody knows how this guy didn't sustain any serious injury - maybe he has super powers of some sort? :wink: Somebody was definately watching over him that night!

I work for the Winnipeg Police Service and part of my job is processing court documents and maintaining all the criminal records on our database. And jail time is a sentence that is rarely handed out here. Christ - about 90% of sexual offenders never go to jail....they usually get a conditional discharge, suspended sentence or conditional sentence. Some don't even get that...I have seem many charges stayed with only a protection order. It's hard to see that still. Even aggravated assaults like in this case rarely get custody. The main two crimes that almost always get some jail time are robbery and drug trafficking. While these are two very serious crimes, I would still rather see more child molesters or psychopaths like these people in this case behind bars. It can be very frustrating at times.
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)