[mark]

Are we going to take all of the winners and do one final round to determine the greatest Hip song of all time?

[potsie]

Good idea. I would also like to see a round to determine what people consider to be the Hip's weakest song of all-time. Throw in all the big vote getters from round 1 of each album (and maybe exclude the EP this time) and try to get some consensus on what represents the bottom of the bucket for the Hip.

[cochise]

Been done a few times in "The Great Match Up"

What I'd like to see is someone who has tons of bootlegs to go through and determine the best live version of each song from that albums specific tour and put a compilation together. Could be a two disc set, one of all the winners and one of all the songs voted out first round. May bring a little more appreciation to the song actually considered the weakest link.

[Scotty12]

I would also suggest moving all of the weakest link threads into their own sub forum or folder so they dont take up the majority of the first page and bury the other threads.

Perhaps use the votes from weakest link to determine the seeds in a "march madness" bracket style vote?

If we did, should each album start with own 16-seed bracket (with the strongest links initially receiving first round byes) to determine the seed # of each album? I wonder if the results of head to head song battles would produce any different champions than "vote for one song" format.

[direwolf74]

I would also suggest moving all of the weakest link threads into their own sub forum or folder so they dont take up the majority of the first page and bury the other threads.

Good idea. I second this.

[sean.bonner]

I would also suggest moving all of the weakest link threads into their own sub forum or folder so they dont take up the majority of the first page and bury the other threads.

Good idea. I second this.

Unfort I can't create new forums. I'll give Lance a shout and see if he can help us out.