Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

I wish The Hip would do this...
#1

In 2003, Pearl Jam was on tour. They saw a 3 night stand coming up in Mansfield (just outside of Boston). so, they decided to try something a little different. Over the 3 nights, they would play EVERY song that they had played on tour, with no repeats. It got dubbed "The Experiment". The first 2 shows were long, but they still had 44 songs to play night 3. So, they did a 12 song acoustic set BEFORE the opening act, then still did a long full set. Then, all 3 sets were released as official bootlegs.

I bought all 3 and strung them together on my iPod, and it is just amazing having every big song, obscure b-side and a bunch of covers in one huge live set with no repitition.

But every time I hear it, I just think about how amazing it would be if the Hip ever did this. They have such a deep catalog, it would be great to have a set like that for fan...

On a related note, any word on more "live from the vault" concerts being released?
Reply
#2

This should probably be moved to the Tragically Hip discussion section.

Jeff

June 21, 2003 Toronto, ON: SkyDome
July 1, 2004 Toronto, ON: Molson Amphitheatre
November 26, 2004 Toronto, ON: Air Canada Centre
June 24, 2006 Toronto, ON: Historic Fort York
May 10, 2007 Indianapolis, IN: The Vogue
July 14, 2011 Edmonton, AB: Northlands Festival Site
June 30, 2012 Niagara-on-the-Lake, ON: The Commons at Butler's Barracks
January 23, 2013 Edmonton, AB: Rexall Place
July 28, 2016 Edmonton, AB: Rexall Place
Reply
#3

fingernailsonhull Wrote:This should probably be moved to the Tragically Hip discussion section.

That's where I posted it, but it got moved here...
Reply
#4

pearl jam and their "experiments" Confusedcratch:

always making other bands look bad.

Vancouver 1997 Vancouver 1999 I Vancouver 2000 I Vancouver 2002 II Vancouver 2004 Vancouver 2006 I Vancouver 2006 III Vancouver 2006 IV Kamloops 2007 Seattle 2007 Marymoor 2007 Vancouver 2007 Seattle 2009 Vancouver 2009 I Vancouver 2009 II Vancouver 2009 II Abbotsford 2009
Burnaby 2011 Seattle 2012 Kamloops 2013 Vancouver 2014 Vancouver 2015
Reply
#5

Wilco did something similar a few years back. In 5 nights at the Riviera Theatre in Chicago, they played every song they'd released on albums and several they hadn't. It would be pretty incredible to see the Hip do something like this.
Reply
#6

it will never happen
Reply
#7

I think The Hip did a great job mixing things up during their 6 nights at Massey Hall in 09. Something like 70 different songs for those 6 shows. Seemed like a bunch of gems each and every night plus acoustic versions of so many different songs. They really spoiled their fans with that tour.
Reply
#8

Raymond23 Wrote:In 2003, Pearl Jam was on tour. They saw a 3 night stand coming up in Mansfield (just outside of Boston). so, they decided to try something a little different. Over the 3 nights, they would play EVERY song that they had played on tour, with no repeats. It got dubbed "The Experiment". The first 2 shows were long, but they still had 44 songs to play night 3. So, they did a 12 song acoustic set BEFORE the opening act, then still did a long full set. Then, all 3 sets were released as official bootlegs.

I bought all 3 and strung them together on my iPod, and it is just amazing having every big song, obscure b-side and a bunch of covers in one huge live set with no repitition.

But every time I hear it, I just think about how amazing it would be if the Hip ever did this. They have such a deep catalog, it would be great to have a set like that for fan...

On a related note, any word on more "live from the vault" concerts being released?

that's awesome. just tracked all 3 shows down and am looking forward to listening!
Reply
#9

BakersBrew Wrote:it will never happen

who says?
and even if so, isn't it just simply fun to speculate? isn't that part of the point to being on a fan site?
Reply
#10

rivum Wrote:
BakersBrew Wrote:it will never happen

who says?
and even if so, isn't it just simply fun to speculate? isn't that part of the point to being on a fan site?
true...Im sure we all hope it happens..and they did mix it up quite a bit during their last tour.
Reply
#11

I would personally like to see the Hip play the entire Day for Night album live, and release it as a concert DVD. Another band I like, Clutch, recently did this with one of their classic records.
Reply
#12

I wish the Hip would ... come back to Australia!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)