Q104s Top Canuck Rockers Of All Time (Halifax Radio)

Q104s Top Canuck Rockers Of All Time (Halifax Radio) - Printable Version

+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: Q104s Top Canuck Rockers Of All Time (Halifax Radio) (/showthread.php?tid=9576)

Pages: 1 2

Q104s Top Canuck Rockers Of All Time (Halifax Radio) - sean.bonner - 12-04-2006

Q104 has compiled a list of the top 104 Canadian rock acts of all time. Look. Laugh. Argue. Debate.
<a class="postlink" href="http://www.q104.ca/index.asp?ObjID=5031">http://www.q104.ca/index.asp?ObjID=5031</a>

- tth_fan - 12-04-2006

Can't argue with #1!!

But come one, Nickelback at #5???...There's no way they're better than the Guess Who (8th), Sloan (11), and Gord Downie (54)!!!
What a load of crap in that aspect...

p.s. I don't consider Lavigne a rocker...

- elliot g - 12-04-2006

It's absolutely ridiculous that Loverboy would beat The Band, and putting them one ahead is just insult to injury (24, 25). Whoever thinks working for the weeknd is a better song than The Weight needs to be slapped, then shown The Last Waltz.

- Sohi - 12-04-2006

I can't believe theory of a dead man are ahead of 5440

- tfoe - 12-04-2006

Sohi Wrote:I can't believe theory of a dead man are ahead of 5440

Yup...that's a load of bull. Come to think of it, 54.40 at #33 is a disgrace. Top 10 - 15 for sure

- The Darkest Canuck - 12-04-2006

here's a good list...created off the top of my head, ENJOY :lol:!

1. Neil Young
2. Rush
3. The Tragically Hip
4. The Guess Who
5. Gordon Lightfoot
6. The Band
7. Sarah McLachlan
8. The Tea Party
9. Matthew Good Band/Matthew Good
10. 54-40
11. Sloan
12. BTO
13. Skinny Puppy
14. Big Sugar
15. Headstones
16. Moist
17. I Mother Earth
18. Junkhouse
19. The Odds
20. Sam Roberts
21. Blue Rodeo
22. April Wine
23. Sam Roberts
24. Our Lady Peace
25. Treble Charger

- tfoe - 12-04-2006

I also think that Neil Young has got to be second over April Wine and that Big Sugar got the shaft at #29.

Still, can't argue with #1!!

- surferguy - 12-04-2006

HOw about ranking of theroy of a deadman and The Trews far higher than Moist and IME... I mean come on!! IME I can see but you cannot deny that Moist was on the forefront push of Canadian Alternative Indie.... Your telling me that the trews and TOAD have more credability???

Also note the ranking of Big Sugar... This list needs to DIAF

- surferguy - 12-04-2006

Oh Shit this list completely shafted Canadian Idol heartthrob Kaylen Porter...

***Turns nead to VOMIT***

- Almost Hip - 12-04-2006

pretty much a Joke of list considering they had to throw Gord in on his own and Chad Kroeger even though their bands are represented, suprised I didn't see Edwin

pissed that Headstones are so far down the list, what's simple plan doing on there? and Avril?? hell why wasn't Shania on there too,

good to see some underdogs like Biff and Danko,

and is Joel Plascid Emergency really that good?? if it wasn't for them opening for the Hip I wouldn't know who they are and they didn't sound that great to top all the other bands

- kleh - 12-04-2006

i looked & laughed, now ill debate that these lists dont really mean anything (same with mmm's 'listed' etc...) but i wont argue about # 1 that's a no brainer, but i just looked and laughed again (#55!)

- Corby - 12-04-2006

oh, the error of catalogues and lists

- day_for_night - 12-04-2006

hahaha matthew good band on that list at all is funny. that guy is such a tool...

- Sohi - 12-04-2006

i am suprised jimmy swift was on there along with I Mother Earth

- cferneyh - 12-04-2006

Sweet! I haven't seen Barney Bentall on any lists since my "music I listened to in high school that kind of embarrasses me now" list.