PunBB
Best Live Hip series release? - Printable Version

+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: Best Live Hip series release? (/showthread.php?tid=5418)

Pages: 1 2

Best Live Hip series release? - HandsInTheRiver41 - 02-07-2005

Which is your favourite of the 3 releases?

- emperor penguin - 02-07-2005

London had the best setlist so I had to go with that one, it was tough though I was at the Canada Day show and the London show. You just can't beat Lake Fever, Twist My Arm, Locked in the Trunk of a Car, 700 ft. Ceiling, Hiccups/Daredevil, Scared and Long Time Running all on the same night....spectacular!!!!!!

- Chris Tanz - 02-11-2005

I voted for Toronto, but it's the only one I've purchased, so I really shouldn't be expressing an opinion.

But from the looks of the results, I should be chasing after the London show.

ct

- The Horrible Esthete - 02-11-2005

This is the best use of the poll function I've witnessed. Makes for an excellent resources for prospective LR buyers.

:thumb:

- Gangrel - 02-11-2005

London was great, but Ottawa had a hairstandingonmyneck rendition of Grace, (come on, let's dance, it's a protest dance party!) and 100th where he bent the mike stand... (I rode the shit outta it!)

Any show with Grace is good in my books. Wink

- ShannonW - 02-11-2005

I chosE Ottawa, but I was there. THe show was phenomenal though, and the rendition of ABAC on it is so good it makes me want to cry. But... i don't. I swear. Smile

- robert goulet - 02-11-2005

My vote is for Ottawa...as a matter of fact I've felt inspired to put it on as I write this...now I haven't heard the other concerts, and I was at the Ottawa show, so it gets the emotional attachment vote.
I loved that part in 100th too, when Gord's going off on the Mic stand "he's just pissed off cuz I bent the shit out of him!!!!" "you're not gonna run away are ya Paul???.....THAT'S A MAN....you're a microphone stand....HE'S A MAN!!!!!!"
Good rendy of Makeshift as well....still LOVE that song.

Goulet!!!

- skippy the wonder dog - 02-11-2005

I wasn't at any of these shows, and I didn't listen to any of the recordings, but my vote is for London because I once met a cute girl from there. :roll:

- babybe - 02-11-2005

I was at both London and the Canada Day show. London gets my vote!!! That show rocked, FRONT and CENTRE didn't hurt either!!!!!!

- Cpt. Trips - 02-12-2005

Once again, Londons version of lake fever made me feel like a new Hip fan all over again, it was amazing.

Drink till you drop!

- hipfan39 - 02-12-2005

Tough! But the Ottawa gets alot of play from me! So i voted for Ottawa

- Stephen Dame - 02-12-2005

Ottawa. Gord has taken in recent interviews to describing Hip fans as "Music Lovers." When the boys begin to play "Are We Family" the place erupts like it's a Top Ten hit. Music lovers indeed.

- john cage - 02-14-2005

I voted for Ottawa since it sounds the best, imo.

If this were a poll of best setlist, my choice is London.

- BigRon - 02-15-2005

I just downloaded the Ottawa show, and am just getting through it the first time. The Grace is absolutely fantastic. Worth the download alone!

As far as London goes, it is a very high energy show, with several unbeatable tracks. The Poets, Fever, Locked, Family, Blow, and Bones are some of the best versions I have ever heard. It will be hard to beat it, except for the fact that London doesn't have a Grace.

Ronny Boy

- chicagoblackhawks77 - 02-20-2005

Personally, I vote for the detroit show of 96, or the detroit show of 2004. Both kick ass.

Skippy, you ever read "cannery row"? Best book of all time.