Comments on Forest Edge? - Printable Version

+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: Comments on Forest Edge? (/showthread.php?tid=499)

---

Comments on Forest Edge? - highlander - 12-04-2002

Took me a couple of seconds to get into it but I like it. I'm still miffed why Problem Bears and Ultra Mundane didn't make it onto IVL. They are great songs. I'd love to hear them live.


High

---

- dannya2 - 12-04-2002

I like it
All 3 should have been on IVL
14 songs on a cd is not too much to ask is it?

---

- mrlayance - 12-04-2002

Interesting song.
It did feel alittle folky. I think it needs a few more listens.

I agree with highlander, Problem Bears and Ultra Mundane are amazing songs.

---

- Tiger the Lion - 12-04-2002

I liked it. And for some reason, some of the lyrics seemed really familiar, especially the part about picking up the phone. Maybe some have been surfacing in shows throughout the ages?? Dunno for sure, but I found it odd that way.
It's not as good as Problem Bears or Ultra Mundane, but good nonetheless... slide guitar is a really nice touch.

---

- Roy-at-tth - 12-04-2002

reminds me alot of Gord's solo stuff.

Awesome song.

---

- ron - 12-04-2002

i like this song not as much as the other bonus songs from earlier.
Wonder how many more songs that didn't make the album that are still out there. Here s hoping we get more soon!!!!

---

- prz - 12-05-2002

its a good song, but they probably had a couple borderline decisions in putting songs on and keeping others off...

---

- HipCheck - 12-05-2002

Love the murky, thick slide guitar. Reminds me of Problem Bears actually.

---

- arseface88 - 12-05-2002

i absolutely love this song! i actually prefer this to ultra mundane and problem bears. i love the folky intro, and gord's lyrics are extremely engaging. cool, cool, cool. this deffinitely should have made the record.

---