PunBB
Spotify - Printable Version

+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: Spotify (/showthread.php?tid=16237)

Pages: 1 2

Spotify - schaggs - 09-09-2016

I'm rocking some hip on Spotify at work today - and I can't help but notice two things:

1. No Phantom Power - Not sure why this album didn't make it to Spotify. Anybody know?

2. Springtime in Vienna - the version from "Trouble at the Henhouse" is a live cut, but I can't place it - seems to be from a club show because there's not the din of 15,000+ screaming fans at Cobo Hall, ACC, Woodstock, or Austin City Limits. Anybody know? The mix isn't great, but it's a decent performance.

Re: Spotify - clarke - 09-09-2016

I've noticed that about PP as well. It was on spotify until about 2 months ago. Don't know why it's gone

Re: Spotify - schaggs - 09-09-2016

Or maybe Spotify is just terrible. I miss winamp.

Re: Spotify - knightrider - 11-17-2017

Was going to ask if anyone knows why Phantom Power AND We are the Same are both missing entirely from Spotify (yet for some reason they have that Austin City Limits festival show in addition to all the other officially released albums)? Found this thread from last year. These ommissions seem so random and do not make me happy.

Re: Spotify - carebread - 11-17-2017

knightrider Wrote:Was going to ask if anyone knows why Phantom Power AND We are the Same are both missing entirely from Spotify (yet for some reason they have that Austin City Limits festival show in addition to all the other officially released albums)? Found this thread from last year. These ommissions seem so random and do not make me happy.

Believe PP and WATS are Canadian-only? They're on my Spotify, WATS is marked with (International Version) though.

Re: Spotify - potsie - 11-19-2017

carebread Wrote:
knightrider Wrote:Was going to ask if anyone knows why Phantom Power AND We are the Same are both missing entirely from Spotify (yet for some reason they have that Austin City Limits festival show in addition to all the other officially released albums)? Found this thread from last year. These ommissions seem so random and do not make me happy.

Believe PP and WATS are Canadian-only? They're on my Spotify, WATS is marked with (International Version) though.

I've got all the albums on Spotify (paid Canadian account... not sure if that makes a difference) and 8 of them are marked "International Version". Thugs on DFN on my Spotify is a live cut, which is strange.

Re: Spotify - carebread - 11-19-2017

potsie Wrote:
carebread Wrote:
knightrider Wrote:Was going to ask if anyone knows why Phantom Power AND We are the Same are both missing entirely from Spotify (yet for some reason they have that Austin City Limits festival show in addition to all the other officially released albums)? Found this thread from last year. These ommissions seem so random and do not make me happy.

Believe PP and WATS are Canadian-only? They're on my Spotify, WATS is marked with (International Version) though.

I've got all the albums on Spotify (paid Canadian account... not sure if that makes a difference) and 8 of them are marked "International Version". Thugs on DFN on my Spotify is a live cut, which is strange.

Studio Thugs over here. Weird.

Re: Spotify - schaggs - 11-20-2017

Live thugs here too. DFN international version.
For that matter, Nautical is live too.

Double Edit:

Greasy Jungle, Thugs, and Nautical Disaster are all 100% for sure from 1995-02-10 at Maple Leaf Gardens (!!!!!!)
Thugs and Greasy sound like poor soundboards, or a pro-mic in the crowd type recording. Nautical sounds like a taper to me.

Re: Spotify - sean.bonner - 11-20-2017

I have noticed on Spotify that when it loads my local files, it still plays them as if they're from a certain album.

For example: I have Phish live at MSG on 2017-08-05 loaded as local music files into my Spotify.

When I play Petrichor, it doesn't say that the album is '2017-08-05 - New York, New York', but rather 'Big Boat'.

Maybe this is coming into play here?

Re: Spotify - schaggs - 11-20-2017

Edit to avoid multipost:
- studio version plays on my phone
- local tracks turned off on PC spotify
- free version of Spotify
- still getting live versions that are different from the bootlegs I have (same show, different sound)- here's the song link: <!-- m --><a class="postlink" href="https://open.spotify.com/track/0sVAQyynQgKVTVKRXxQA0C">https://open.spotify.com/track/0sVAQyynQgKVTVKRXxQA0C</a><!-- m -->

I'm interested to know if that link opens up studio or live version.

Re: Spotify - potsie - 11-20-2017

I just checked and Thugs is also live on my computer Spotify, and studio on my phone. Gord prefaces the song by saying "Here is a song about the way Dustin Hoffman treats women"... is that the 1995 MLG show? The live version also has some "skips" in it.

Re: Spotify - mark - 11-20-2017

potsie Wrote:I just checked and Thugs is also live on my computer Spotify, and studio on my phone. Gord prefaces the song by saying "Here is a song about the way Dustin Hoffman treats women"... is that the 1995 MLG show? The live version also has some "skips" in it.

He said it at the Halifax 1995 show

Re: Spotify - potsie - 11-20-2017

mark Wrote:
potsie Wrote:I just checked and Thugs is also live on my computer Spotify, and studio on my phone. Gord prefaces the song by saying "Here is a song about the way Dustin Hoffman treats women"... is that the 1995 MLG show? The live version also has some "skips" in it.

He said it at the Halifax 1995 show

That's interesting. Spotify "knows" I live in Halifax so I wonder if it intentionally inserted a song from a Halifax show or if it is pure concidence.

Re: Spotify - schaggs - 11-21-2017

I don't know what's going on, but I don't hear that in Thugs.
I get "We'd like to take you way back now to a time of... (women?)"
Greasy Jungle starts with "It's time to lift up your apron and do the dishes"

I don't understand what's going on. The internet has officially made me feel old.

Re: Spotify - mark - 11-21-2017

potsie Wrote:
mark Wrote:
potsie Wrote:I just checked and Thugs is also live on my computer Spotify, and studio on my phone. Gord prefaces the song by saying "Here is a song about the way Dustin Hoffman treats women"... is that the 1995 MLG show? The live version also has some "skips" in it.

He said it at the Halifax 1995 show

That's interesting. Spotify "knows" I live in Halifax so I wonder if it intentionally inserted a song from a Halifax show or if it is pure concidence.

hello fellow Maritimer.

the halifax show was a Live Vault release, that's probably what is going on