Match up : #29 - Printable Version
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+---- Forum: [Hip 64] - The Great Match Up (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=22)
+---- Thread: Match up : #29 (/showthread.php?tid=11747)
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+---- Forum: [Hip 64] - The Great Match Up (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=22)
+---- Thread: Match up : #29 (/showthread.php?tid=11747)
Pages:
1
2
Match up : #29 - Shane Kroeker - 04-14-2008
Match-up #29 - Silver Jet Vs. At the Hundredth Meridian
Listen to the two songs in the match-up Back to Back, and consider the lyrics of the song. Feel free to post an unbiased analysis of both songs in this thread, but please refrain from cheerleading or making predictions for your favourites.[/quote]
*Note the time of this post - Poll closes in 24 hours.
- sean.bonner - 04-14-2008
If Silver Jet gets 10%, I'll be surprised.
...But damn, I'd still like to see it live.
- Zenith - 04-14-2008
Damn, another tough one. I'm one of the Silver Jet fans.
- joshwayy - 04-14-2008
blow out..
- laliber - 04-14-2008
Zenith Wrote:Damn, another tough one. I'm one of the Silver Jet fans.
I hear ya!
- Cookie.factory_West.Wind - 04-14-2008
Hundredth, but only for the garbage bag tree bit.
- BrenTheodore - 04-14-2008
Zenith Wrote:Damn, another tough one. I'm one of the Silver Jet fans.
Completely agree. Silver Jet will get the bill, but if they were live recordings...
- tth_fan - 04-15-2008
I'm a bigger fan of the studio version then the live versions of ATHM... so it gets my vote because it's a better studio song then SJ
- screw_ball - 04-15-2008
Silver Jet is by far the worst song ever written by the Hip.
- Zenith - 04-15-2008
tth_fan Wrote:I'm a bigger fan of the studio version then the live versions of ATHM... so it gets my vote because it's a better studio song then SJ
I was thinking along the same lines. I find ATHM to be a bit hit or miss live, where as every version of SJ I've heard live has been great. SJ doesn't come across as well on the studio version as ATHM.
Are these match ups judged on the studio versions alone?
- robert goulet - 04-15-2008
Jet gets skipped EVERY time I come to it...just a terrible song. I can't believe they kept Problem Bear off of IVL and kept a song like Jet on. I'd like to have a chat with whoever made that decision.
- EPenguin10 - 04-15-2008
Zenith Wrote:Really? Apart from the last time I saw them (Brussels '07), I thought ATHM was great live (from '96 - '02)...tth_fan Wrote:I'm a bigger fan of the studio version then the live versions of ATHM... so it gets my vote because it's a better studio song then SJ
I was thinking along the same lines. I find ATHM to be a bit hit or miss live, where as every version of SJ I've heard live has been great. SJ doesn't come across as well on the studio version as ATHM.
Are these match ups judged on the studio versions alone?
- emperor penguin - 04-15-2008
robert goulet Wrote:Jet gets skipped EVERY time I come to it...just a terrible song. I can't believe they kept Problem Bear off of IVL and kept a song like Jet on. I'd like to have a chat with whoever made that decision.
Or Forest Edge, I'm surprised Silver Jet made it through the relegation round last year..
- Zenith - 04-15-2008
EPenguin10 Wrote:Zenith Wrote:Really? Apart from the last time I saw them (Brussels '07), I thought ATHM was great live (from '96 - '02)...tth_fan Wrote:I'm a bigger fan of the studio version then the live versions of ATHM... so it gets my vote because it's a better studio song then SJ
I was thinking along the same lines. I find ATHM to be a bit hit or miss live, where as every version of SJ I've heard live has been great. SJ doesn't come across as well on the studio version as ATHM.
Are these match ups judged on the studio versions alone?
Yeah, sometimes. Maybe it's my mood at the time. I always enjoy hearing the studio version but I don't always enjoy it live (at least, not as much).
- emperor penguin - 04-15-2008
Zenith Wrote:EPenguin10 Wrote:Zenith Wrote:Really? Apart from the last time I saw them (Brussels '07), I thought ATHM was great live (from '96 - '02)...tth_fan Wrote:I'm a bigger fan of the studio version then the live versions of ATHM... so it gets my vote because it's a better studio song then SJ
I was thinking along the same lines. I find ATHM to be a bit hit or miss live, where as every version of SJ I've heard live has been great. SJ doesn't come across as well on the studio version as ATHM.
Are these match ups judged on the studio versions alone?
Yeah, sometimes. Maybe it's my mood at the time. I always enjoy hearing the studio version but I don't always enjoy it live (at least, not as much).
I agree, I just think it sounds better on the album.. it has a dark eeriness too it, the mood of the song gets changed live and it loses its dark atmosphere