Match Up #2 - Printable Version
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+---- Forum: [Hip 64] - The Great Match Up (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=22)
+---- Thread: Match Up #2 (/showthread.php?tid=10206)
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+---- Forum: [Hip 64] - The Great Match Up (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=22)
+---- Thread: Match Up #2 (/showthread.php?tid=10206)
Pages:
1
2
Match Up #2 - Hard Canadian - 03-13-2007
....not trying to step on your toes here shane, i just figured i'd make the post for matchup #2 just so people have the chance to vote today, please don't take offence by this. i want to try and vote on all 32 match-ups and i don't know if i'll have the chance to online later this evening..... the leafs have a big game tonight. 8)
anyways, let the voting begin!
- sean.bonner - 03-13-2007
Do you think we should lock each forum after the poll has passed?
- Shane Kroeker - 03-13-2007
thehip420 Wrote:....not trying to step on your toes here shane, i just figured i'd make the post for matchup #2 just so people have the chance to vote today, please don't take offence by this. i want to try and vote on all 32 match-ups and i don't know if i'll have the chance to online later this evening..... the leafs have a big game tonight. 8)No problem 420, I had a meeting this afternoon with one of the wealthiest CEO's in Winnipeg, so I couldn't get to a computer... Thanks for starting it this time, and also thanks to Lance for setting up the sub-forum!
anyways, let the voting begin!
sean.bonner Wrote:Do you think we should lock each forum after the poll has passed?It probably isn't necessary, as the poll automatically is locked after 24 hours. If we leave it unlocked, people can still make comments on the songs or results after the vote is over, even if they missed voting. But, if it does become a problem in the future, I would consider locking the thread.
- borgs - 03-13-2007
this one's no fair.
how are the matchups being generated?
- Shane Kroeker - 03-13-2007
borgs Wrote:this one's no fair.The thing is.. It's too fair. Each song has been randomly assigned to it's match-up. I used numbered each song, then used a table of random digits to determine the match-ups. This was to ensure that there were no biases on my behalf, and that each song had an equal chance of being pitted against the hardest opponent, or one of the weaker B-sides. As they say, It's just the luck of the draw, and if this event is a success this year, your favourite songs may be given an easier match-up next year!
how are the matchups being generated?
- kleh - 03-13-2007
that was the toughest decision i had to make in awhile
- opiated - 03-13-2007
kleh Wrote:that was the toughest decision i had to make in awhile
no kiddin..almost a physical impossibility, but penguin won out in the end
- john cage - 03-13-2007
After 2 match ups, I gotta say these are difficult choices.
How about Grace v. Coconut Cream? :mrgreen:
I picked Sherpa since it's been killer live lately. If they'd play Penguin I probably would've abstained from this vote.
- QuizShowChampion - 03-13-2007
Emperor Penguin for me. You know the songs that aren't the straight out rock ones like New Orleans Is Sinking or ballads like ABAC? The ones with cool guitar parts that just seem to float and you listen to for hours? Emperor Penguin is one of those. I love the way they layer the guitar and the lyrics/vocals are especially moving.
That being said my mouse hovered over the Sherpa option for a long time because that song has got some wicked lyrics.
- bobcaygeonriot - 03-14-2007
I'm for Sherpa. It just steals me every. single. time. without hesitation.
- sean.bonner - 03-14-2007
It's kind of cool to see these similar songs compete (Similar as in, near the end of an album and not as well known). I hope there becomes a matchup of some polar opposites, like Long Time Running vs. Poets.
I can't wait to pick my brain tomorrow at what to choose. This kicks ass!
- tigerthelion - 03-14-2007
Gotta go for 'Sherpa'. Just the line, "we must be friends or die, and we've died a thousand times since then" is enough for me.
- Naga - 03-14-2007
I used to Emperor Penguin on repeat. Recently, too, actually. I listened to one after the other today, though, and Sherpa is getting me emotional, so it gets my vote.
- Zenith - 03-14-2007
Sherpa is really cool - especially live, but I think that Emperor Penguin just has the edge for me at this moment in time.
QuizShowChampion Wrote:You know the songs that aren't the straight out rock ones like New Orleans Is Sinking or ballads like ABAC? The ones with cool guitar parts that just seem to float and you listen to for hours? Emperor Penguin is one of those. I love the way they layer the guitar and the lyrics/vocals are especially moving.
I know what you mean. 8)
- RJB - 03-14-2007
Will these polls run on the weekend? I'm thinking about cancelling my internet here at my place, but if that means I can't vote on the weekend, then I don't think I will cancel it.
However, if it just runs during the work week, I can do it at work.
Anyone? This is damn sweet! It's too bad we couldn't include EVERY song somehow.