PunBB
"Liveponymous" - Printable Version

+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: "Liveponymous" (/showthread.php?tid=6689)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

- Lizard King - 08-18-2005

Billy Wrote:Forgive my ignorance, but is this a Live version of the songs off of Hipeponymous, or a live disc of songs we collectively choose? Either wat is cool, just not sure which angle you're taking.
What he's trying to do is get a live version of every song on Hipeponymous, basically a copy-cat cd just all live.

- joshwayy - 08-20-2005

Ok, haven't gathered all of these shows yet but here is the updated list. I'd like to finish the tracks for Disk 1 today so I'm looking for ABAC, Cordelia, & Wheat Kings.

I've tried not to use duplicate shows, but my collection is no where as big as others and some shows are so good I will likely have to use them again. Also, some of these tracks are mp3, some are flac, and some are shn. I'll need to convert them all to one or the other. What is the appropriate way to go? Is it bad to make a mp3 into a flac? I don't know the "tapers protocol", but I would assume it is frowned upon.

As of now, Get Back Again has the slight edge over Thugs, but in light of recent events and the fact the Gems didn't make the cut- I'm going with the version of Gems with Thugs rant I have from the HipMan's Vault #2. I don;t know where it is from, I think it was from '93.

Thanks to everyone who has offered help...keep it coming.

2. Grace, Too- Gino 12/0794
3. My Music At Work- Boston 7/28/02
4. 38 Years Old- Hengelo 05/24/91
5. Gift Shop- Katana 11/29/96
6. Ahead By A Century __________
7. Vaccination Scar 12/04/04 Sydney
8. Three Pistols 11/27/00 Saskatoon
9. So Hard Done By Hampton Beach '98
10. Fiddler's Green ??
11. Looking For A Place To Happen 11/28/00 Brandon
12. Cordelia ____________
13. "It's A Good Life If You Don't Weaken" Queen's Jubilee on 10/04/02
14. Blow At High Dough 1991 The Roxy
15. Wheat Kings __________
16. 50 Mission Cap- Day for night promo (what show was this from?)
17. New Orleans Is Sinking- Pink Pop 05/06/95
18. Escape Is At Hand For The Travelin' Man Austin 10/14/00

- chris - 08-20-2005

Can we get Cordelia from the MuchMusic Intimate and Interactive where the fan sang with Gordie?

And I'm sure that I've got a cool version of Wheat Kings with Ashley MacIsaac somewhere....

- Billy - 08-20-2005

chris Wrote:Can we get Cordelia from the MuchMusic Intimate and Interactive where the fan sang with Gordie?

And I'm sure that I've got a cool version of Wheat Kings with Ashley MacIsaac somewhere....

I hate that version. I always skip over that because the guy can't sing well and I find it more embarrassing than anything else. Cool for him that he got up and did it, but it's not my cup o' tea.

- chris - 08-20-2005

Billy Wrote:
chris Wrote:Can we get Cordelia from the MuchMusic Intimate and Interactive where the fan sang with Gordie?

And I'm sure that I've got a cool version of Wheat Kings with Ashley MacIsaac somewhere....

I hate that version. I always skip over that because the guy can't sing well and I find it more embarrassing than anything else. Cool for him that he got up and did it, but it's not my cup o' tea.
Very true. I probably should've written my post like this:
[sarcasm]Can we get Cordelia from the MuchMusic Intimate and Interactive where the fan sang with Gordie?[/sarcasm]
:oops:

- Lizard King - 08-20-2005

ok we need a sarcasm smiley bad around here...lance can you make it happen?

- kieffer - 08-20-2005

1996-11-29 Kanata wheat kings sounds really good and gord says a nice thanks to all the crew for setting up!

- Summiteer - 08-20-2005

I prawly havent heard alot of the versions of Wheat Kings as some of you, but I'd say Ottawa 93's gotta be the best I've heard :thumb:

- kelman66 - 08-22-2005

joshwayy Wrote:Ahead by A Century:

Montreal 12/7/00

One of my favorites. Slightly slower than normal and you can clearly hear Paul kicking ass on his vocals.

Any other stand out versions I should consider?

My fave is the 'Dirty' version from Pink Pop 95. That was really in the middle of NOIS with Cookie Factory.... That whole business is a gem that cant be left off IMHO.

*edit* Why not replace Fiddler's with Unplucked Gems from Nachtwerk, Germany 2-8-1993 (misc. grab bag dvd)
mesmerizing.
That Bavarians, is how you paint a room.
I think Cordelia is on there too, not positive. awesome show.

- j-monster - 08-22-2005

kelman66 Wrote:
joshwayy Wrote:Ahead by A Century:

Montreal 12/7/00

One of my favorites. Slightly slower than normal and you can clearly hear Paul kicking ass on his vocals.

Any other stand out versions I should consider?

My fave is the 'Dirty' version from Pink Pop 95. That was really in the middle of NOIS with Cookie Factory.... That whole business is a gem that cant be left off IMHO.

If you're going to consider versions of NOIS with the "Dirty" ABAC rant, the one they played in Rochester, NY in April 1995 is absolutely stellar, in my opinion.

- joshwayy - 08-25-2005

Y'all may have herd that the pink pop show is fer sur my favoreeet. I'd put evree song on the comp..ill...a....shon on it if it'wer my choise.

In fact I might just do thaty here....

- joshwayy - 09-04-2005

So this is the first time in way too long that i have had a chance to jam to some tunes and put thought to the "Live" version of the upcoming release.

I'm not one to let things die, so I'm forging onward...to disk two I say...mount up. Any and alll nominations are welcomed...I am comprizing a list of my own and will update weekly. Completion is scheduled for months end...(thirty days has sept...)...Sept 30th!

Pm me or post...for suggestions and assistance...thanks.


"Yer Favourites" Disc Two
1. Fully Completely:
2. Twist My Arm:
3. Courage:
4. Lake Fever:
5. Poets:
6. Fireworks:
7. Boots Or Hearts:
8. Bobcaygeon:
9. Nautical Disaster:
10. Highway Girl:
11. Gus: The Polar Bear From Central Park:
12. Scared:
13. Something On:
14. At The Hundredth Meridian: '95 Pink Pop Smile~
15. Long Time Running:
16. The Darkest One:
17. Locked In The Trunk Of A Car:
18. Little Bones:
19. The New Maybe (New Song): ?

- emperor penguin - 09-05-2005

For Scared you should use the 10/24/2000 version from The Fillmore in San Francisco. This version has Kate Fenner sing a few lines with Gord, it's phenominal.

- Lizard King - 10-09-2005

joshwayy Wrote:I'm not one to let things die, so I'm forging onward...to disk two I say...mount up. Any and alll nominations are welcomed...I am comprizing a list of my own and will update weekly. Completion is scheduled for months end...(thirty days has sept...)...Sept 30th!
Sept. 30th has passed, whats the latest josh? Is thing ever going to come to fruition? I was looking forward to it. Maybe we can get it done by Nov.1 so it coincides with Hipeponymous? If your still in need of songs make a list of what you are still needing, maybe I have some songs I can give you to help speed things up.

- joshwayy - 10-10-2005

Ya, this has been nagging me. Been short-handed at work and putting in extra time. Things are just now dying down, so I'll get back on this task and at least get the song selection done for d2. I haven't gotten much feedback for the songs for disk 2. I was hoping to not have songs from the same concert, but my selection of shows, and obviously the quality of the recordings is making this unlikely. Also, the songs I have picked are a combination of flac and mp3...I'll have to transfer all of the songs to mp3 if this is going to work. And finally...I'll have to learn how to upload a torrent (I know...I've just been lazy)

I have the time to work on this tomorrow...so look into your catalogs and send suggestions for songs for d2.