In View -- One Year Later - Printable Version
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: In View -- One Year Later (/showthread.php?tid=10770)
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: In View -- One Year Later (/showthread.php?tid=10770)
- fingernailsonhull - 06-22-2007
I'm ambivalent toward In View.
IMO, the best on WC are:
Luv
Drop-Off
Rink
LNIDYDLM
Band
- Lizard King - 06-22-2007
Chris Tanz Wrote:opiated Wrote:One year later, it's still just a song..get over it...
hey, at least it got two pages worth of posts in one day which is more than any other non NHL topic on the 'base these days.
In View stinks, and it's not just a song, it's a terrible song. Dare I say it? ... it is worse than ... Evelyn.
There, I said it.
ct
Ill take Evelyn over In View anyday.. :thumb:
- daylight - 06-22-2007
I'm still okay with it, always have been. It's really nice when you're in the right mood. The only WC song that's not on my mp3 player is Pretend. I hope that song gets permanently dropped from the live set sooner than later!
- opiated - 06-22-2007
cferneyh Wrote:opiated Wrote:One year later, it's still just a song..get over it...
:thumb:
what happened to us?? when did we fall in love
- VioletlightHeron - 06-23-2007
opiated Wrote:cferneyh Wrote:opiated Wrote:One year later, it's still just a song..get over it...
:thumb:
what happened to us?? when did we fall in love
The radio DJ and the stat cruncher..oy vey now there's a Felix and Oscar type of marriage!
:lol:
- cochise - 06-25-2007
In View is The Hips "Miss You". A song you never expected to hear fom them, you don't really like too much, pretty weak when compared to all of their other material, almost too radio friendly, and a song you would rather not hear in concert............but then half way through find yourself singing along...............
"I've been walkin' Central Park, singin' after dark, people think I'm craazzzy"............ :thumb:
Re: In View -- One Year Later - The Horrible Esthete - 06-25-2007
Chris Tanz Wrote:Can anyone even stomach listening to this song anymore? I tried to listen to it yesterday and gave up about a minute in. Blech.
I never could stomach it.
Chris Tanz Wrote:My World Container contains only the following:
Yer Not the Ocean
Fly
Kids
Drop Off
Family Band
World Container
Wow, CT. My WC is almost identical, but has LNIDYDLM instead of Drop Off.
hipgirl from stratford Wrote:In view is a girly song, I never thought the male fans would dig it. I think its a cute song but it only appeals to certain people, you really have to be in a perky, giddy, childlike mood to get into it.
:lol: Hear that, Mr. In-View Lover? Blasting it in your car may draw the wrong kind of attention, if you know what I mean.....
chris Wrote:I heard it on the radio today and it sounded almost out of place on a new rock station.
Well, if it's on a "rock" station, then it is out of place.
VioletlightHeron Wrote:I think the fact that the band had to create a bubblegum pop piece of schlock in order to get more radio airplay speaks to the sad sad state of commercial radio.
Agreed. But i'm more concerned with why the band feels it needs to get radio airplay at this stage of the game.
j-monster Wrote:And I certainly don't understand some people's dislike of Rink. The soaring guitars at the intro and throughout, the dramatic, hockey imagery in the lyrics, the almost Police-like feel to the beat... I think it's one of the best songs on the album.
direwolf74 Wrote:Couldn't agree more. Rink is easily one of my favorites on the album, and it never fails to kick my ass when they play it live. When I first heard it at Sasquatch '06, my friends and I immediately declared it an instant Hip classic. Robby's Police-esque guitar part is what makes the song, and the dance-rock breakdown during the bridge parts is pretty damn cool too. I especially love Johnny's perfectly timed rim-shots during the 2nd verse.I hear what you guys are saying, and when I must don my "critic hat", I might even be forced to echo some of your sentiments, but for some reason I just don't enjoy listening to Rink, which is odd. Usually, if I can appreciate the technical aspects and overall construction of a song, I default to enjoying and appreciating said song. But in general, I just don't seem to enjoy this one.
However, I have found that if I focus my attention on Sinclair's bassline, I wind up enjoying the experience because Sinclair is..well....frickin awesome.....
cochise Wrote:In View is The Hips "Miss You". A song you never expected to hear fom them, you don't really like too much, pretty weak when compared to all of their other material, almost too radio friendly, and a song you would rather not hear in concert............but then half way through find yourself singing along...............
Uhhhh....no. That's a terrible analogy. "Miss You" might be a little out-of-line with what the Stones typically "do", but is nonetheless a bad-ass tune with a groovy bassline. "In View", on the other hand, is complete cheese that made for twelve-year-olds and Nancies.
Re: In View -- One Year Later - cochise - 06-25-2007
The Horrible Esthete Wrote:cochise Wrote:In View is The Hips "Miss You". A song you never expected to hear fom them, you don't really like too much, pretty weak when compared to all of their other material, almost too radio friendly, and a song you would rather not hear in concert............but then half way through find yourself singing along...............
Uhhhh....no. That's a terrible analogy. "Miss You" might be a little out-of-line with what the Stones typically "do", but is nonetheless a bad-ass tune with a groovy bassline. "In View", on the other hand, is complete cheese that made for twelve-year-olds and Nancies.
I never thought of it as a bad ass tune, I just can't get past the disco bass line..............................just my opinion though.......
Re: In View -- One Year Later - The Horrible Esthete - 06-25-2007
cochise Wrote:I never thought of it as a bad ass tune, I just can't get past the disco bass line
Disco, by and large, is (or was, circa Some Girls) a very 'adult' scene. The disco beat of "Miss You" is a funky, sexy groove; it's "Saturday Night"; it's "sweaty club"; it's "bump and grind" to something a heckuva lot closer to rock and roll than hip-hop.
"In View" is "hang at the mall", "slumber party", and "let's do each other's makeup after school".
- Billy - 06-25-2007
insert name here Wrote:I think In View...blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah blah
I dunno...I still like it.
Actually, when I heard it live in Calgary last November, I thought the song was really lacking because there wasn't any "cheesy" synthesizer in it.
- chives - 06-25-2007
cochise Wrote:In View is The Hips "Miss You". A song you never expected to hear fom them, you don't really like too much, pretty weak when compared to all of their other material, almost too radio friendly, and a song you would rather not hear in concert............but then half way through find yourself singing along...............
"I've been walkin' Central Park, singin' after dark, people think I'm craazzzy"............ :thumb:
As long as the Hip don't perform In View with Justin Timberlake, I can manage it. It's a good song, not a great song. I'm very surprised no one compared the opening of Rink to a Zeppelin-esqe song. "Rock and Roll", or "The Song Remains the Same"....the type of songs that build to a climax...Great drum and guitar work
Re: In View -- One Year Later - VioletlightHeron - 06-25-2007
The Horrible Esthete Wrote:VioletlightHeron Wrote:I think the fact that the band had to create a bubblegum pop piece of schlock in order to get more radio airplay speaks to the sad sad state of commercial radio.
Agreed. But i'm more concerned with why the band feels it needs to get radio airplay at this stage of the game.
I would hazard a guess that the record company asked them to create some radio friendly songs so the record would garner more attention and, theoretically, sell more records.
I also don't understand the love for WC itself. To my ears, the lyrics are pretty good but the arrangement sounds like something Liberace or Queen would put together.
Re: In View -- One Year Later - skippy the wonder dog - 06-25-2007
My God, has it really been a year? I was thinking that the world had generally gone to hell for some time. Now it all makes sense.
The Horrible Esthete Wrote:"In View" is "hang at the mall", "slumber party", and "let's do each other's makeup after school".
:thumb:
VioletlightHeron Wrote:I also don't understand the love for WC itself. To my ears, the lyrics are pretty good but the arrangement sounds like something Liberace or Queen would put together.
That was more or less my reaction. The title track is particularly Queenish.
But these days, Queen is in. So....
- tnannic - 06-25-2007
In View might be a cheesey pop single, but its success is in large part its irony and the way it references and plays with the conventions of the cheesey pop song genre. The video really helped me to think about the song in this regard--it's like a laundry list of references to and plays on pop music video conventions and cliches. I think it's a smart, great song.
But I think World Container is the weakest album in years. In my opinion, the first three tracks are stong. Fly, Luv (Sic), and The Kids Don't Get It are mediocre at best. Pretend and Last Night I Dreamed You Didn't Love Me are among the worst the band has ever recorded. Things pick up again with The Drop Off and Family band, which are both solid tunes. And then there is World Container... This track is such a great indication of the central problem of this album: Its producer. World Container itself is not a bad song at all--as I think is evinced by live performances of it--but the production choices are terrible. A piano and strings? It's like the irony of the lyrics went completely over Bob Rock's head. The music is so earnest and maudlin it makes me uncomfortable. A friend of mine put it best: It sounds like theme music for a Disney movie.
To sum up: I think Bob Rock has got to go--now.
- direwolf74 - 06-25-2007
tnannic Wrote:To sum up: I think Bob Rock has got to go--now.
I totally agree with all of you regarding the over the top Queen-like production on the title track, but that's the only track that bothers me. I think Bob did a great job on the rest of the album. Sure, the production has a bit more gloss than previous Hip albums, but I thought he captured the rhythm section perfectly. Johnny's drums have never sounded better and Sinclair is much higher in the mix than usual, which is great, because as Esthete mentioned in his post, Sinclair is freakin' awesome. Like may people here, I was worried about what the album would sound like with Rock behind the boards, but I was pleasantly surprised when I heard the final results.
Having said that, I do hope that World Container was just an experiment and that they choose a different producer for the next record.