PunBB
"Liveponymous" - Printable Version

+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: "Liveponymous" (/showthread.php?tid=6689)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8

- MAverick - 08-09-2005

joshwayy Wrote:Sweet. I was going to create a topic for each song and give a 3 day voting period... get some suggestions... poll them up so we have majority rule, but I like MAv's idea better. Would you put up the submission forms here on on thehip.com? I would be more than happy to tabulate ballots.

There are certainly others more skilled at pulling something like this off than I.

HAven't thought that far ahead. What I will do is something like this:

Create a form that has a dropdown for each song. Each will be blank. There will be a link to submit a version of the song or something if the version that you want isn't there.

Then you can just select the version that you vote for, or add a new one.
Results will be tabulated automatically

Anyway, that's more or less what I was thinking.

MAv.

- joshwayy - 08-09-2005

What a way to pass the day...is it a coincidence that there are 24 hours in a day and 24 beers in a case?...hmmm...1st question- what to replace Fiddler's Green with? I supose Get Back Again would be a logical choice, but I am also wishing Thugs or Sherpa made the list....

Here is my personal list for the 1st disk so far:

2. Grace, Too- Gino 12/0794
3. My Music At Work- Boston 7/28/02
4. 38 Years Old- Hengelo 05/24/91
5. Gift Shop- Katana 11/29/96
6. Ahead By A Century
7. Vaccination Scar
8. Three Pistols
9. So Hard Done By
10. Fiddler's Green
11. Looking For A Place To Happen
12. Cordelia
13. "It's A Good Life If You Don't Weaken"
14. Blow At High Dough
15. Wheat Kings
16. 50 Mission Cap- Day for night promo (what show was this from?)
17. New Orleans Is Sinking- Pink Pop 05/06/95
18. Escape Is At Hand For The Travelin' Man Austin 10/14/00

Throw any standouts my way....

- Lizard King - 08-09-2005

I guess Get Back Again would be a good replacement. But I like the idea of putting Thugs on it, I think it deserved to be on it, and I have a great version from Chicago 2002-07-18. If you go with it.

Cool idea by the way!

- Billy - 08-09-2005

Titanic Terrarium from "Freaked In Sweden"...for two reasons.

1) The song itself sends goosebumps down my spine everytime I listen to it.

2) The Swedish dude you can hear yelling the Little Bones lyrics, right at the beginning...priceless.

- Lizard King - 08-09-2005

Billy Wrote:Titanic Terrarium from "Freaked In Sweden"...for two reasons.

1) The song itself sends goosebumps down my spine everytime I listen to it.

2) The Swedish dude you can hear yelling the Little Bones lyrics, right at the beginning...priceless.
Good call Billy, I love that song and that version from Sweden is top notch. :thumb:

It gives me goosebumps too when I hear it, such a killer opening.

- Billy - 08-09-2005

Now, if Mav were any kind of guy, he'd delve into the "Hip Vault" and pull out the SDB copies of all these songs and release this compilation to Hipbasers.
















...a guy can dream can't he?

- Summiteer - 08-09-2005

joshwayy Wrote:16. 50 Mission Cap- Day for night promo (what show was this from?)

Logo,Hamburg Germany 1992

- srb - 08-09-2005

joshwayy Wrote:1st question- what to replace Fiddler's Green with?

That could be another poll question

- joshwayy - 08-09-2005

I'd like to use some of the Woodstock show, but all I have is one large MP3 file...how do I break it up?...Bueller....Bueller...I mean Chris...I know you know....

- ikky99 - 08-09-2005

MAverick Wrote:
joshwayy Wrote:Sweet. I was going to create a topic for each song and give a 3 day voting period... get some suggestions... poll them up so we have majority rule, but I like MAv's idea better. Would you put up the submission forms here on on thehip.com? I would be more than happy to tabulate ballots.

There are certainly others more skilled at pulling something like this off than I.

HAven't thought that far ahead. What I will do is something like this:

Create a form that has a dropdown for each song. Each will be blank. There will be a link to submit a version of the song or something if the version that you want isn't there.

Then you can just select the version that you vote for, or add a new one.
Results will be tabulated automatically

Anyway, that's more or less what I was thinking.

MAv.

This guy's just unbelievable!!! Where have you been all our lives?

- chris - 08-09-2005

joshwayy Wrote:I'd like to use some of the Woodstock show, but all I have is one large MP3 file...how do I break it up?...Bueller....Bueller...I mean Chris...I know you know....

I use Quicktime Pro for Mac to split them up... not sure about the PC options.

- j-monster - 08-09-2005

This would be AMAZING if you guys pulled this off. My hat's off to all of you for even thinking about taking on this kind of project.

- willthenurse - 08-10-2005

I would be super stoked to get a live version of all their greatest hits! I really cannot contribute anything to helping make the list, i could vote a bit but I dont have much of the old hip bootlegs anymore (I have the three shows from live downloads and a few others (hwy grl suicide and killerwhaletank for example.).

anyway, great idea, I love it and look forward to seeing where this ends up going!

~Will.

- habsfan19 - 08-10-2005

Killer project indeed
Great idea, bigger project would be to do like Pearl Jam fans and
have DVDs with best live versions, but that's another one for another day I think

- chris - 08-10-2005

habsfan19 Wrote:Killer project indeed
Great idea, bigger project would be to do like Pearl Jam fans and
have DVDs with best live versions, but that's another one for another day I think

LOL... It's almost as if you read my mind... I mean my post earlier in this thread...

Along with some other stuff... I Wrote:....I've seen this done on other fan sites... Pearl Jam fans even did it with video, and put out album-by-album compilation DVDs of the best live performances of each song!

:thumb: