The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - Printable Version
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+---- Forum: The Weakest Link (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=33)
+---- Thread: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 (/showthread.php?tid=16689)
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+---- Forum: The Weakest Link (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=33)
+---- Thread: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 (/showthread.php?tid=16689)
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - Moof_Milker - 11-23-2017
edgoffin Wrote:All the Fireworks haters from the other thread can get their vengeance with this poll.They said they never gave a fuck about Fireworks...and I never saw someone say that before.
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - gsmacleod - 11-23-2017
After much debate, it's The Rules for me. Just not quite as solid as the rest of the album.
Shane
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - carebread - 11-23-2017
Membership is one of my favourites, I'll be damned if it's bowing out first!
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - potsie - 11-23-2017
Happily voting for Fireworks. I was thinking that I'd get multiple opportunities to do so, but it appears there is a strong contingent of those who don't care for it. It's a bathroom break tune for me.
It's clear early on that this poll is going to culminate in a "Hits" vs. "Deep Cuts" showdown, Poets and Bobcaygeon vs. Escape and Emperor.
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - Moof_Milker - 11-23-2017
carebread Wrote:Membership is one of my favourites, I'll be damned if it's bowing out first!I feel the sting of the votes for this too. I love the dark tone of Membership. The way Gord sings this one sounds to me like his live voice in recent years -- a deeper register with the hint of a growl. The way he punches "banks" in the line "...river over-spilling its banks" sounds dark and ominous. :twisted: But...what are the alternatives to vote for? I picked "The Rules" ...maybe because of its tone - light, airy, little wistful perhaps? Nothing wrong with that...but compared to other songs it sounds maybe less important...if that makes sense.
I thought about voting for Save The Planet too...but that Ron Burgundy-esque flute solo at the end is just too fun to ignore. Maybe it'll get my 2nd round vote.
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - carebread - 11-23-2017
Moof_Milker Wrote:carebread Wrote:Membership is one of my favourites, I'll be damned if it's bowing out first!I feel the sting of the votes for this too. I love the dark tone of Membership. The way Gord sings this one sounds to me like his live voice in recent years -- a deeper register with the hint of a growl. The way he punches "banks" in the line "...river over-spilling its banks" sounds dark and ominous. :twisted: But...what are the alternatives to vote for? I picked "The Rules" ...maybe because of its tone - light, airy, little wistful perhaps? Nothing wrong with that...but compared to other songs it sounds maybe less important...if that makes sense.
I thought about voting for Save The Planet too...but that Ron Burgundy-esque flute solo at the end is just too fun to ignore. Maybe it'll get my 2nd round vote.
Fireworks. I can't get into it.
I feel like Membership is the best song for Paul vocals.
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - Killer Whale Tank - 11-23-2017
Ya know what? I screwed up my vote! Somehow I completely forgot about the album's only complete piece of sh*t, Save the Planet, and voted against the merely adequate Chagrin Falls instead. D'OH!
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - direwolf74 - 11-23-2017
Killer Whale Tank Wrote:Ya know what? I screwed up my vote! Somehow I completely forgot about the album's only complete piece of sh*t, Save the Planet, and voted against the merely adequate Chagrin Falls instead. D'OH!
Lol, I love Save the Planet. One of my favorite tunes on the album.
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - Killer Whale Tank - 11-23-2017
Bleech - it has zero going for it as a composition, IMHO. Clumsy melody, lousy, unmemorable chorus, 'meh' lyrics by GD's standards. Useless. But good news, it was a by-default beneficiary of my incompetent poll-responding :mrgreen:
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - Moof_Milker - 11-23-2017
Killer Whale Tank Wrote:Bleech - it has zero going for it as a composition, IMHO. Clumsy melody, lousy, unmemorable chorus, 'meh' lyrics by GD's standards. Useless....so I'm gonna go ahead and put you down for a 'no' on that flute solo then
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - Chris Tanz - 11-23-2017
Fireworks deserves odium because it is a song that I don't want to hear at a concert. But it is a song that there is a chance will be heard at a concert because it is not as weak as The Rules. So The Rules gets the first vote.
The buzzards will easily pick off The Rules, Chagrin Falls, Save the Planet, and Odium-Deserving Fireworks. Then they'll crack the carcass of Membership, Thompson Girl, and Vapour Trails. Something On will go after we realize it hung on too long. Or Vapour Trails and Something On will swap fates. Then we'll duke it out for the big boppers (Poets and BobC) against Escape and Emperor Penguin. In every other timeline BobC beats Poets in an exhausting Game 7, people reminiscing about their cottage and beers and bongs and wearing some shirt and laying down in the dewy grasses of youth, but in this -- the HIpbase timeline, the darkest timeline (oh and you're the Darkest One) -- Penguin and Escape go to the wire and the universe implodes and the Cubs win the World Series over the Indians after an extra inning rain delay and we all wake up like wreckage on the shores of Baby Beach wondering what happened.
Or did I just dream that?
ct
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - Escape@Hand - 11-24-2017
direwolf74 Wrote:Killer Whale Tank Wrote:Ya know what? I screwed up my vote! Somehow I completely forgot about the album's only complete piece of sh*t, Save the Planet, and voted against the merely adequate Chagrin Falls instead. D'OH!
Lol, I love Save the Planet. One of my favorite tunes on the album.
Me too, I love that song! I don't understand why it got dropped from their setlists so quickly. I remember having front row for that tour and they opened with that song, it was great! I wish I could have heard it more than once live (same with Emperor Penguin, although I at least heard it once).
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - potsie - 11-24-2017
Chris Tanz Wrote:Fireworks deserves odium because it is a song that I don't want to hear at a concert. But it is a song that there is a chance will be heard at a concert because it is not as weak as The Rules. So The Rules gets the first vote.Did the phone ring? I breathlessly read your post and then you just left me hanging at the end.... who wins? I need to know how it all ends.
The buzzards will easily pick off The Rules, Chagrin Falls, Save the Planet, and Odium-Deserving Fireworks. Then they'll crack the carcass of Membership, Thompson Girl, and Vapour Trails. Something On will go after we realize it hung on too long. Or Vapour Trails and Something On will swap fates. Then we'll duke it out for the big boppers (Poets and BobC) against Escape and Emperor Penguin. In every other timeline BobC beats Poets in an exhausting Game 7, people reminiscing about their cottage and beers and bongs and wearing some shirt and laying down in the dewy grasses of youth, but in this -- the HIpbase timeline, the darkest timeline (oh and you're the Darkest One) -- Penguin and Escape go to the wire and the universe implodes and the Cubs win the World Series over the Indians after an extra inning rain delay and we all wake up like wreckage on the shores of Baby Beach wondering what happened.
Or did I just dream that?
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - Chris Tanz - 11-24-2017
^^ Then the dream ends when the phone rings. You're doing all right. Nautical won. It's 1995. These other songs haven't been released yet. There's no need to choose between Emperor Penguin and Escape is at Hand.
You wanna see how it ends? The door is just starting to open. [Stereo/Best Friends starts to play ...]
Re: The Weakest Link - Phantom Power - Round 1 - Killer Whale Tank - 11-24-2017
Save the Planet got dropped from setlists early for the obvious reason that it sucks :mrgreen:
Chris Tanz, is that a certain jadedness about this 'Weakest Link' process setting in - ?