World Container Reviews - Official Thread - Printable Version
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: World Container Reviews - Official Thread (/showthread.php?tid=9099)
+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=4)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/forumdisplay.php?fid=7)
+--- Thread: World Container Reviews - Official Thread (/showthread.php?tid=9099)
- deadparrot - 10-13-2006
I hope i don't wear this CD out. I think i've listened almost 10 times now. Here's my order:
Pretend
Luv (sic)
Fly
Yer Not The Ocean
The Drop-Off
In View
The Kids Don't Get It
Lonely End of the Rink
Last Night I dreamed
Family Band
World Container
World Container.
- The Tragically Hip - 10-13-2006
I love the lyric
"Or be beaten by the sweetest of deeks"
Some great songs on this release
Family band
Yer not the ocean
Fly
In view
Luv
The drop off
World container
"I can smell a rat when its all rat"
- googolplex - 10-13-2006
Wow, I don't know how I overlooked it, but I just came to the realization that Family Band is a killer song. There is not a weak song at all on this album.
- sundin13 - 10-13-2006
googolplex Wrote:Wow, I don't know how I overlooked it, but I just came to the realization that Family Band is a killer song. There is not a weak song at all on this album.
It makes you wonder why they buried it at the back of the album, when it's arguably one of the best songs on the record...
- googolplex - 10-13-2006
Indeed, Drop Off -> Family Band -> World Container may be the most consistent final three tracks on any Hip album ever.
- Jenna_Bird - 10-13-2006
googolplex Wrote:Indeed, Drop Off -> Family Band -> World Container may be the most consistent final three tracks on any Hip album ever.
Be that as it may, I think the top spot is occupied by Phantom Power's trifecta of Chagrin Falls, Escape and Emperor Penguin.
However, this set may grow on me -- it's early yet.
-Jenna
- tigerthelion - 10-13-2006
I don't even listen to Arcade Fire but I'm pretty confident that the Hip aren't copying them since The Hip have been around for more than 20 years and there are 5000 bands that are better than the Arcade Fire and more worthy of copying.
- emperor penguin - 10-13-2006
googolplex Wrote:Indeed, Drop Off -> Family Band -> World Container may be the most consistent final three tracks on any Hip album ever.
I think Train Overnight, The Bear and AIWDTP is the best 3 song finisher
- sundin13 - 10-13-2006
Another spot-the-influence query -- does any one else think the catchy guitar riff in Luv (sic) sounds like Unforgettable Fire-era U2?
- The Horrible Esthete - 10-13-2006
Jenna_Bird Wrote:googolplex Wrote:Indeed, Drop Off -> Family Band -> World Container may be the most consistent final three tracks on any Hip album ever.
Be that as it may, I think the top spot is occupied by Phantom Power's trifecta of Chagrin Falls, Escape and Emperor Penguin.
I cannot see these 3 WC tracks superceding the 3 final PP tracks. No way, no how. If something like "Kids" or "Fly" were to replace "Family Band, then perhaps, accounting for the unknown "grow-on-me" quantity of these WC tracks, they could rival those killer PP tunes.....perhaps
I still would highly doubt it.....
- sundin13 - 10-13-2006
The Horrible Esthete Wrote:I cannot see these 3 WC tracks superceding the 3 final PP tracks. No way, no how. If something like "Kids" or "Fly" were to replace "Family Band, then perhaps, accounting for the unknown "grow-on-me" quantity of these WC tracks, they could rival those killer PP tunes.....perhaps
I still would highly doubt it.....
Kick out "Family Band"? Sorry, HE, I'd ditch one of the other two in a heartbeat. One of the best Hip tracks in a while, IMO.
- Chris Tanz - 10-13-2006
The Horrible Esthete Wrote:Jenna_Bird Wrote:googolplex Wrote:Indeed, Drop Off -> Family Band -> World Container may be the most consistent final three tracks on any Hip album ever.
Be that as it may, I think the top spot is occupied by Phantom Power's trifecta of Chagrin Falls, Escape and Emperor Penguin.
I cannot see these 3 WC tracks superceding the 3 final PP tracks. No way, no how. If something like "Kids" or "Fly" were to replace "Family Band, then perhaps, accounting for the unknown "grow-on-me" quantity of these WC tracks, they could rival those killer PP tunes.....perhaps
I still would highly doubt it.....
Really? Chagrin Falls? Really? I'd say Escape plus Emperor is the best 1-2 closer and that Chagrin is along for the ride. You wouldn't have an Ohio bias, would you?
ct
- googolplex - 10-13-2006
Yeah, not that I don't love Chagrin falls, but Escape and Emperor are clearly the standouts.
- Spycouple - 10-13-2006
Jenna_Bird Wrote:Be that as it may, I think the top spot is occupied by Phantom Power's trifecta of Chagrin Falls, Escape and Emperor Penguin.
-Jenna
YES! That is the best 1-2-3 I think as well. If they ever opened a show or an encore with those three in order, it would be pretty sweet. And then the new record in its entirety, followed by Ultra Mundane. Or, alternately, any selection of songs off of their catalogue. I'm not picky.
-jf
- The Horrible Esthete - 10-13-2006
Chagrin Falls, to me, typifies the stong suits of this band. Dramatic construct, great vocal melody, a darker mood, provocative lyrics, and Gord turning the intensity up to 11 in concert with the musical patterns...
No profound sound no special effects
The continent tipped and she just quietly left
Chagrin falls on our heads
Not in a gush but in maddening droplets
When GD cranks this verse up to the next octave, i get a rush of adrenaline and goosebumps to this very day.
It's almost too early to say this, knwing the propensity for Hip tunes to "grow", but:
I think Chagrin blows "Family Band" out of the water. I think FB is the second weakest cut on this album. To glossy, too flaky -- too "In View".