PunBB

Full Version: best and worst comic book movies
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
i'm bored..so..this is the best i could come up with today...i know i'm in the minority, but i love HULK..i think it's a great movie, that totally captured the mood of the comic book...a classic monster movie, that was totally marketed and hyped all wrong...people expected something else, and didn't get it..i just hope he gets a sequal....
as for other good comic movies, Batman Begins, Spider Man 2 and XMEN stand out to me...
as for the worst...Batman Forever, Daredevil, The Punisher, and although i haven't seen it, i hear Fantastic Four is utter crap
Best:
Spidey
Spidey 2 (still the best one I've seen)
Batman Begins
Batman (Tim Burton version)
Superman (Christopher Reeve kicks ass!)
Superman 2
X-Men
X-Men 2
The Crow
Hulk (not great, but not bad either)
Blade
Blade 2
Men in Black

Worst:
Daredevil (Ben Affleck should never, ever play a superhero)
Batman Forever
Batman & Robin
Elektra (haven't seen it, but I've heard it's a steaming pile of crap)
Fantastic 4 (see Elektra)
The Shadow
The Punisher
Dick Tracy (hated it)
Tank Girl
The Phantom
Men in Black 2


That's all I can think of at the moment.
what about sin city? i thought it was pretty good
farmerdan69 Wrote:what about sin city? i thought it was pretty good

Damn, good call! I can't believe I forgot about that one. That movie is amazing.
Spiderman 2, Batman Begins, X-Men and X-Men 2 are my favourite comic book movies. Tim Burton's original Batman was great for mood & atmosphere, and special effects, but lacked a little bit in plot & storyline.

I haven't seen many of the movies voted by you guys as worst comic book movies, but I remember seeing The Phantom and thinking it was cheesy as all get-out. Thank goodness it was only a rental.
the original tim burton batman (jack and the joker was great!)
batman begins was awesome.

I thought the punisher was a great movie, tonnes of violence, great one liners

travolta: you killed my son
(building blows up)
punisher: yeah, both of them

i still chuckle...

spiderman 1&2, x-men 1&2, and sin city was a great movie as well.


daredevil, batman 3&4 (despite the actors in it, they were pretty good cartoons of the villians, carey (riddler), ah-nold (mr.freeze), uma thurman (poison ivy), tommy-lee jones (two-face), im sure im forgetting some, ut anyway, i digress....

i just saw the fantastic 4, i thought it was OK, but i never really liked the comic, so now being "grown-up" the movie was so-so,. great effects though.

~Will