PunBB

Full Version: Are The Hip "brilliant" or just "pretentious"?
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2 3
<!-- m --><a class="postlink" href="http://www.kingstonwhigstandard.com/ArticleDisplay.aspx?e=1537797">http://www.kingstonwhigstandard.com/Art ... ?e=1537797</a><!-- m -->

There was quite a debate happening at the site above (in the comments section). Confusedcratch:
Reminds me of an interview the Hip did with "The New Music" (old Muchmusic show) at the beginning of the Canadian leg of the DFN tour in '95. Host Jana Lynne White asked Gord & Paul which description they prefered: "The Tragically Hip's music is brilliant"...or "their music is twisted", to which Gord replied: "either one leads to insanity."
That's a pretty funny argument. Not one single person makes a good point.
I think the take home message there is "There are no stupid questions, just stupid people" (Mr.G)

Here is the funniest snippet of the bunch
"the HIP "brilliant"???? - I don't think they can touch Beethoven."

They should put this on a shirt. On my Rheostatics Box set I put together Dave mentions Tim Perlich's Now Magazine review of Whale Music where he said "It looks like art if you squint" which they then put on the back of one of their shirts.

Incidentally if you are a Rheostatics fan - go to my http://www.rheostaticslive.com site and go to the "Static Journey" tab which is my 200+ track 9 part Rheostatics Box Set, band sanctioned, downloadable, free and 14 hours long.
I could not give a duck's nut about any of the band members having a trust fund. Yeah I am still Confusedcratch: trying to figure out what the point is that anyone was making.
So jonny sucks, having rich parents make you suck, and rob 'drives around town with his "chic" in a huge SUV, Blowin cash faster than he makes it!'. Obviously.
sherpa Wrote:On my Rheostatics Box set I put together Dave mentions Tim Perlich's Now Magazine review of Whale Music where he said "It looks like art if you squint" which they then put on the back of one of their shirts.

Incidentally if you are a Rheostatics fan - go to my http://www.rheostaticslive.com site and go to the "Static Journey" tab which is my 200+ track 9 part Rheostatics Box Set, band sanctioned, downloadable, free and 14 hours long.

Ahh...so you're the one who put together that massive Rheos box set. That thing is awesome. Well done!

:thumb:
Amongst all the crazy comments made in that 'discussion', the one that bothered me most is the crack about American beer. Watery beer has a place in life. Whether it's Bud or Blue, Molson or Coors. Sometimes you need a lighter beer to gulp down. Do I want a hoppy beer at the beach? A heavy wheat beer at a ball game? No and no. Give me something light and slurpable. And if you have problems with American beer, then I'm guessing you've never had a Brooklyn Lager Pennant Ale, a Fat Tire, or hell even a Sam Adams Boston Lager. But I digress; back to the topic at hand...
brilliant....obviously
sherpa Wrote:I think the take home message there is "There are no stupid questions, just stupid people" (Mr.G)

Here is the funniest snippet of the bunch
"the HIP "brilliant"???? - I don't think they can touch Beethoven."

They should put this on a shirt. On my Rheostatics Box set I put together Dave mentions Tim Perlich's Now Magazine review of Whale Music where he said "It looks like art if you squint" which they then put on the back of one of their shirts.

Incidentally if you are a Rheostatics fan - go to my http://www.rheostaticslive.com site and go to the "Static Journey" tab which is my 200+ track 9 part Rheostatics Box Set, band sanctioned, downloadable, free and 14 hours long.
Woah. I had no idea this existed! That looks intense. I will definitely listen to it... eventually.
mastodonfarm Wrote:Amongst all the crazy comments made in that 'discussion', the one that bothered me most is the crack about American beer. Watery beer has a place in life. Whether it's Bud or Blue, Molson or Coors. Sometimes you need a lighter beer to gulp down. Do I want a hoppy beer at the beach? A heavy wheat beer at a ball game? No and no. Give me something light and slurpable. And if you have problems with American beer, then I'm guessing you've never had a Brooklyn Lager Pennant Ale, a Fat Tire, or hell even a Sam Adams Boston Lager. But I digress; back to the topic at hand...

What do American beer and making love in a canoe have in common?
Heh, I'll bite...
Billy Wrote:
mastodonfarm Wrote:Amongst all the crazy comments made in that 'discussion', the one that bothered me most is the crack about American beer. Watery beer has a place in life. Whether it's Bud or Blue, Molson or Coors. Sometimes you need a lighter beer to gulp down. Do I want a hoppy beer at the beach? A heavy wheat beer at a ball game? No and no. Give me something light and slurpable. And if you have problems with American beer, then I'm guessing you've never had a Brooklyn Lager Pennant Ale, a Fat Tire, or hell even a Sam Adams Boston Lager. But I digress; back to the topic at hand...

What do American beer and making love in a canoe have in common?

They're both fucking close to water?
screw_ball Wrote:
sherpa Wrote:I think the take home message there is "There are no stupid questions, just stupid people" (Mr.G)

Here is the funniest snippet of the bunch
"the HIP "brilliant"???? - I don't think they can touch Beethoven."

They should put this on a shirt. On my Rheostatics Box set I put together Dave mentions Tim Perlich's Now Magazine review of Whale Music where he said "It looks like art if you squint" which they then put on the back of one of their shirts.

Incidentally if you are a Rheostatics fan - go to my http://www.rheostaticslive.com site and go to the "Static Journey" tab which is my 200+ track 9 part Rheostatics Box Set, band sanctioned, downloadable, free and 14 hours long.
Woah. I had no idea this existed! That looks intense. I will definitely listen to it... eventually.

It was a huge project which I put together after their final show 2 years ago - it is a chronological history of the band from 1980 to 2007 and includes demos, interviews, live songs, stage banter and studio cuts. It is one take on their history again but overall it has interesting or unique selections. It is broken up into albums/eras so that it is a bit less daunting than one giant project. There are also some notes on the site about each volume to give it some context.
mastodonfarm Wrote:Amongst all the crazy comments made in that 'discussion', the one that bothered me most is the crack about American beer. Watery beer has a place in life. Whether it's Bud or Blue, Molson or Coors. Sometimes you need a lighter beer to gulp down. Do I want a hoppy beer at the beach? A heavy wheat beer at a ball game? No and no. Give me something light and slurpable. And if you have problems with American beer, then I'm guessing you've never had a Brooklyn Lager Pennant Ale, a Fat Tire, or hell even a Sam Adams Boston Lager. But I digress; back to the topic at hand...

I never had Fat Tire until I moved to Wyoming. It's now one of my favorites.

I miss Yuengling, though, being out west.
Pages: 1 2 3