Match-up #30 - Chagrin Falls Vs. Membership
Listen to the two songs in the match-up Back to Back, and consider the lyrics of the song. Feel free to post an unbiased analysis of both songs in this thread, but please refrain from cheerleading or making predictions for your favourites.
Membership is still the only Hip song I really dislike.
Chagrin Falls is one of the songs on PP that I liked immediately. Membership took a while to grow on me, but I think it's a great song. The beauty of Membership is in the lyrics (no surprise in a Hip song). Still, it's not enough for me to vote for it over Chagrin Falls, which has great lyrics and better melody.
I can't believe this is a poll. Membership is in my LEAST likeable pile.
I'm quite surprised by the comments. Membership follows right after EP for me in order of preference on PP.
EPenguin10 Wrote:I'm quite surprised by the comments. Membership follows right after EP for me in order of preference on PP.
I second that.
grimes Wrote:EPenguin10 Wrote:I'm quite surprised by the comments. Membership follows right after EP for me in order of preference on PP.
I second that.
Thirded
Great Waiting List Wrote:grimes Wrote:EPenguin10 Wrote:I'm quite surprised by the comments. Membership follows right after EP for me in order of preference on PP.
I second that.
Thirded
4thited --hosers :music
Chagrin Falls is clearly better.
I'll have to go with Membership, but not an overwhelming choice....songs are very close IMO
This is like choosing between two good beers.