Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5

2009 Relegation Round
#1

32 songs are vulnerable (songs knocked out in first round). 9 of these songs will be ineligable to compete in next year's tournament. This will provide spots for 10 new competitors into the competition to keep next year's tournament fresh.

Post your list of the 10 songs you think are the weakest from the list. Then search through the Hip's extensive catalogue to replace them in next year's tourney.
*Only select songs that have been officially released on a Tragically Hip CD. No Demos/Rarities will be considered. Also make sure that the songs you select were not involved in the 2009 tournament.

Vulnerable Songs
700 ft Ceiling
Another Midnight
Apartment Song
Blow at High Dough
Bobcaygeon
Boots or Hearts
Eldorado
Fight
Flamenco
Goodnight Josephine
Greasy Jungle
Inevitability of Death
It Can't Be Nashville Every Night
Leave
Little Bones
Looking For A Place To Happen
Membership
Morning Moon
Put It Off
Sharks
Sherpa
Silver Jet
So Hard Done By
Something On
Springtime in Vienna
The Dire Wolf
The Luxury
Thompson Girl
Thugs
Twist My Arm
Vaccination Scar
Wheat Kings

Valid Lists should appear in the following format:
Out:
AAA
BBB
CCC
...

In:
MMM
NNN
OOO
...
Reply
#2

Out:
Another Midnight
Bobcaygeon
Leave
Looking For A Place To Happen
Membership
Sharks
Silver Jet
Springtime in Vienna
The Luxury
Vaccination Scar

I don't remember what needs to go back in.
Reply
#3

700 ft Ceiling
Another Midnight
Apartment Song
Blow at High Dough
Bobcaygeon
Boots or Hearts
Eldorado
Fight
Flamenco
Goodnight Josephine
Greasy Jungle
Inevitability of Death
It Can't Be Nashville Every Night
Leave
Little Bones
Looking For A Place To Happen
Membership
Morning Moon
Put It Off
Sharks
Sherpa
Silver Jet
So Hard Done By
Something On
Springtime in Vienna
The Dire Wolf
The Luxury
Thompson Girl
Thugs
Twist My Arm
Vaccination Scar
Wheat King

OUT:
The Dire Wolf
The Luxury
So Hard Done By
Thugs
It Cant Be Nashville
Greasy Jungle
Blow @ High Dough
Sharks
Sherpa

IN:
Queen Of The Furrows
Depression Suite
Love Is A First
Speed River

I forget old ones that werent in it lol
Reply
#4

Out:
700 ft Ceiling
Apartment Song
Fight
Leave
Membership
Morning Moon
Put It Off
Sherpa
The Luxury
Vaccination Scar

In:
Are You Ready?
As Makeshift As We Are
Coffee Girl
Everytime You Go
Fireworks
Let's Stay Engaged
One Night in Copenhagen
The Completists
The Depression Suite
When The Weight Comes Down

Apologies for any errors in the "in" list.
Reply
#5

Out:
Apartment Song
Eldorado
Flamenco
Goodnight Josephine
It Can't Be Nashville Every Night
Membership
Morning Moon
Put It Off
Sherpa
Thompson Girl

In:
Are You Ready?
Fireworks
When The Weight Comes Down
The Struggle Has A Name
The Depression Suite
Exact Feeling
Queen of the Furrows
Speed River
Frozen in my Tracks
Love is a First
Country Day
Reply
#6

Thanks for organizing Hip 64!

Out:
Inevitability of Death
Looking for a place to happen
It can’t be Nashville
Silver Jet
Leave
Sharks
Membership
Fight
700 feet ceiling

In:
We’ll go too
The completists
Fireworks
Depression Suite
Last Recluse
Queen of the Furrows
Love is a First
Country Day
Struggle has a name
World Container
Reply
#7

Hey guys, I'm new here. Just signed up in time to get in on the voting as Locked beat Ahead by a Century. Love the idea of the Hip 64!

Out:
Another Midnight
Apartment Song
Flamenco
Goodnight Josephine
Greasy Jungle
Morning Moon
Silver Jet
The Luxury
Thompson Girl
Thugs

In:
Last Recluse
Coffee Girl
Now The Struggle Has A Name
The Exact Feeling
Queen of the Furrows
Country Day
As Makeshift as we are
When the Weight Comes Down
World Container
We'll Go Too
Reply
#8

Out:
700 ft Ceiling
Apartment Song
Fight
It Can't Be Nashville Every Night
Leave
Put It Off
Sharks
Silver Jet
The Luxury
Twist My Arm

In:
We'll Go Too
The Bear
An Inch An Hour
Highway Girl
The Depression Suite
Now the Struggle Has A Name
Speed River
Queen of the Furrows
Frozen in My Tracks
The Last Recluse
Reply
#9

Out:
Vaccination Scar
Apartment Song
Blow at High Dough
Courage
50 Mission Cap
100th Meridian
Eldorado
Fight
So Hard Done By
Put It Off
Sharks
Sherpa
Silver Jet

In:
The Depression Suite
Last American Exit
Small Town Bringdown
When the Weight Comes Down
She Didn't Know
Lionized
Boots or Hearts
Family Band
The Last Recluse
Now The Struggle Has A Name
Fly (Former Rants are always worthy)
Reply
#10

Out:
Another Midnight
Fight
It Can't Be Nashville Every Night
Sharks
The Luxury
Leave
Membership
Silver Jet
Goodnight Josephine
Twist my arm

In:
Depression Suite
We'll Go too
The Last Recluse
Frozen In my Tracks
Now the Struggle has a name
Love is a First
Heart of the Melt
The Wherewithal
Queen of the Furrows
Makeshift we are
Reply
#11

OUT:
700 Ft. Ceiling
Another Midnight
Apartment Song
Eldorado
Greasy Jungle
Put It Off
Sharks
Sherpa
The Luxury
Thugs

IN:
A Beautiful Thing
Born in the Water
Bring it all Back
Coffee Girl
Fireworks
The Last Recluse
Luv (sic)
The Rules
Toronto #4
You're Everywhere
Reply
#12

JT_Stone Wrote:Out:
[13 songs listed]

In:
[11 songs listed]

Shane Kroeker Wrote:Post your list of the 10 songs you think are the weakest from the list. Then search through the Hip's extensive catalogue to replace them in next year's tourney.
...

JT_Stone: It says 10 and 10, not 13 and 11
Reply
#13

Here is a friendly reminder to start thinking about submitting your picks. I will announce the firm deadline for relegation entries in February. The tournament will again begin in March!
Reply
#14

Out

Bobcaygeon
Vaccination Scar
700 Ft. Ceiling
Thompson Girl
Wheat Kings
Inevitability Of Death
Apartment Song
Membership
The Dire Wolf
Morning Moon

In

Tiger The Lion
I'll Believe In You (Or I'll Be Leaving You Tonight)
The Drop-Off
Use It Up
The Bear
In View
Toronto #4
Mean Streak
Freak Turbulence
Throwing Off Glass

2004-12-03 - Saint John/2005-09-03 - Moncton/2006-06-30 - Charlottetown/2006-11-09/10 - Montreal/2007-09-11 - Fredericton/2007-09-13 - Halifax/2007-09-14 - Sydney/2007-09-15 - Charlottetown/2008-06-30 - Charlottetown/2009-05-01/02 - Montreal/2011-06-28 - Moncton/2011-06-30 - Charlottetown/2012-06-30 - Niagara-on-the-Lake/2013-02-01 - Moncton/2013-02-02 - Halifax/2015-01-10 - Toronto/2015-02-20 - Montreal/2015-07-17 - Ottawa/2016-08-18 - Ottawa/2016-08-20 - Kingston
Reply
#15

The relegation round will end on Tuesday, February 23, 2010. Please be sure to have your selections in and edited before that time. This is your chance to influence the Tournament at its earliest stage!
Reply


Forum Jump:


Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)