Match up #36 - Printable Version

+- PunBB (https://punbb.in)
+-- Forum: General Discussion - Hipbase.com (https://punbb.in/Forum-General-Discussion-Hipbase-com)
+--- Forum: Tragically Hip Discussion (https://punbb.in/Forum-Tragically-Hip-Discussion)
+---- Forum: [Hip 64] - The Great Match Up (https://punbb.in/Forum-Hip-64-The-Great-Match-Up)
+---- Thread: Match up #36 (/Thread-Match-up-36)

---

- EricStoner - 04-16-2007

Its probably too early, but ya this is definitely going to be a close one. I loved Family Band live when I heard it in feb. DWD just doesn't move me that much. had to go with Family

---

- SunnydaleSpike - 04-16-2007

do what you want...
do what you feel like...
just do not...
DON'T
WAKE
DADDY

---

- sean.bonner - 04-16-2007

EricStoner Wrote:Its probably too early, but ya this is definitely going to be a close one. I loved Family Band live when I heard it in feb. DWD just doesn't move me that much. had to go with Family

...n00b

just kiddin'

---

- QuizShowChampion - 04-17-2007

I always figured the album version wasn't as good as the version on LBU, but upon listening again I'm falling in love with it. It makes me all tingly. I'm torn, because all I've ever wanted to be in was a family band, but the line about fashion sense is just... ARGH DAMN YOU HIPBASE.

In fact, I will whisper that in your ear.

Without waking Daddy.

What a terrible vote. Middleweights that are disgustingly close together.

---

- Bosman - 04-17-2007

I can't believe it's this close. Daddy is one of my all-time favourites.

---

- cochise - 04-17-2007

Sorry, just tied it up with my vote for DWD........34-34

Love Family Band, but Daddy has way too many memories for me............."they can lay their heads on their futon bed a million miles from home, you can teach your children some fashion sense and they fashion some of their own"......................classic

---

- BRoach - 04-17-2007

family band is far and away my favourite song on WC

DWD has been a great set opener for a couple shows this past year, but i'd rather hear a set close with family band than one open with DWD..

---

- EricStoner - 04-17-2007

sean.bonner Wrote:

EricStoner Wrote:Its probably too early, but ya this is definitely going to be a close one. I loved Family Band live when I heard it in feb. DWD just doesn't move me that much. had to go with Family

...n00b

just kiddin'

Oh no! You found out my secret!

---

- fingernailsonhull - 04-17-2007

Tough vote man. Had to think about this one for a while.

You can stuff yer void with the asteroid that's hurtlin' toward the earth.

---

- FighterAndLover - 04-17-2007

Bosman Wrote:I can't believe it's this close. Daddy is one of my all-time favourites.

I can't believe it either, but for different reasons :lol:

General concensus on the forum seems (to me) to be Family Band is the favourite song on WC. Trouble at the Henhouse seems (to me) to get little-no talk on the forums.

I don't know. But my vote put Family Band up.

---

- trevor - 04-17-2007

Go FAMILY Go!

---

- Chris Tanz - 04-17-2007

this is nail-biting stuff. they've been neck and neck all day.

if they're tied, is there a shootout-style tiebreaker. You know, you play one note or recite one lyric from each song to decide it.

ct

---

- emperor penguin - 04-17-2007

---

- FighterAndLover - 04-17-2007

emperor penguin Wrote:

haha I kind of want to change my vote now :lol:

---

- Hard Canadian - 04-17-2007

wow, tied 44-44 at 5pm eastern time. maybe i will vote. 8)

edit: well apparently i already voted, i don't remember voting at all. odd. cratch:

---